EdiShorts

The Collegium System Debate: Opacity, Diversity and Judicial Appointments

IssueAugust 2026
PaperGS Paper 2
SubjectPolity & Governance
Read time4 min

Context: The expansion of the Supreme Court's sanctioned strength in August 2026 reopened the older and more fundamental question of how judges are actually chosen — the collegium system, an arrangement found nowhere in the constitutional text, under renewed criticism for opacity and for the persistent under-representation of women, who make up only about 14% of High Court judges.

About the Collegium System

  • It is an extra-constitutional, judge-led mechanism: the Supreme Court collegium comprises the Chief Justice of India and the four senior-most judges; a High Court collegium comprises its Chief Justice and two senior-most judges.
  • Constitutional text: Articles 124 and 217 speak only of appointment by the President "after consultation with" the Chief Justice of India and other judges — the collegium is a judicial construction of that word.
  • Evolution through the Three Judges Cases: First Judges Case (S.P. Gupta, 1981) gave primacy to the executive; Second Judges Case (1993) reversed it, holding "consultation" means "concurrence" and creating the collegium; Third Judges Case (1998), on a Presidential Reference, expanded the Supreme Court collegium to five members.
  • The 99th Constitutional Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014 sought to replace it; both were struck down in 2015 as violating judicial independence, a basic-structure feature.

The Criticisms

  • Opacity: deliberations are not recorded in any publicly reasoned form, so neither rejection nor elevation carries a stated justification that can be scrutinised.
  • Diversity deficit: women hold roughly 14% of High Court judgeships, and representation of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and OBCs in the higher judiciary remains far below population share.
  • Delay: recommendations can sit with the Government for months without formal rejection, giving the executive a de-facto pocket veto that the system was designed to prevent.
  • Absence of a permanent secretariat means the collegium has no institutional capacity to independently assess candidates beyond personal knowledge and circulated reports.

The Defence

  • Judicial independence is basic structure, and the primacy of the judiciary in its own appointments is the mechanism the Court has held necessary to protect it.
  • Executive-dominated models risk appointments turning on political alignment, especially where the Government is the largest single litigant.
  • The Memorandum of Procedure, if finalised and honoured, could deliver transparency without transferring primacy back to the executive.

Way Forward

  • Finalise the long-pending Memorandum of Procedure with published, objective eligibility criteria and reasoned records for recommendations.
  • Establish a permanent secretariat with a searchable, merit-based database of eligible advocates and district judges to widen the candidate pool beyond informal networks.
  • Set enforceable timelines for the Government to act on reiterated recommendations.
  • Adopt transparent diversity targets, particularly for women and for elevation from the district judiciary.

Exam Angle — Prelims & Mains

  • UPSC PYQ Link (Mains 2022, GS Paper 2): "Discuss the desirability of greater representation to women in the higher judiciary to ensure diversity, equity and inclusiveness." — The 14% figure and the collegium's opacity are the two facts that anchor a strong answer here.
  • Practice Mains Question (GS Paper 2, 15 marks, 250 words): "The collegium system protects judicial independence at the cost of transparency and diversity." Critically examine, and suggest reforms that could reconcile the two objectives.
  • Prelims Angle: The Three Judges Cases sequence (1981, 1993, 1998) and the striking down of the 99th Amendment and NJAC Act in 2015 are frequently tested; note also that the collegium appears nowhere in the constitutional text.
    • Practice Prelims MCQ: With reference to the appointment of judges to the higher judiciary in India, consider the following statements:
      1. The collegium system is expressly provided for in Article 124 of the Constitution.
      2. The Third Judges Case (1998) arose out of a Presidential Reference and expanded the Supreme Court collegium to the Chief Justice of India and four senior-most judges.
      3. The National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014 and the 99th Constitutional Amendment were struck down by the Supreme Court in 2015.
      Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
      Options:
      (A) 1 and 2 only
      (B) 2 and 3 only
      (C) 1 and 3 only
      (D) 1, 2 and 3
      Show answer
      Answer: (B) 2 and 3 only — Statement 1 is INCORRECT: Article 124 refers only to appointment by the President after "consultation"; the collegium is a judicial interpretation of that word, not a textual provision. Statements 2 and 3 are correct.

More Polity & Governance from August 2026

Written by the EdiShorts editorial team from official and public sources. Check the latest position before quoting figures in the exam.