Context: The expansion of the Supreme Court's sanctioned strength in August 2026 reopened the older and more fundamental question of how judges are actually chosen — the collegium system, an arrangement found nowhere in the constitutional text, under renewed criticism for opacity and for the persistent under-representation of women, who make up only about 14% of High Court judges.
About the Collegium System
- It is an extra-constitutional, judge-led mechanism: the Supreme Court collegium comprises the Chief Justice of India and the four senior-most judges; a High Court collegium comprises its Chief Justice and two senior-most judges.
- Constitutional text: Articles 124 and 217 speak only of appointment by the President "after consultation with" the Chief Justice of India and other judges — the collegium is a judicial construction of that word.
- Evolution through the Three Judges Cases: First Judges Case (S.P. Gupta, 1981) gave primacy to the executive; Second Judges Case (1993) reversed it, holding "consultation" means "concurrence" and creating the collegium; Third Judges Case (1998), on a Presidential Reference, expanded the Supreme Court collegium to five members.
- The 99th Constitutional Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014 sought to replace it; both were struck down in 2015 as violating judicial independence, a basic-structure feature.
The Criticisms
- Opacity: deliberations are not recorded in any publicly reasoned form, so neither rejection nor elevation carries a stated justification that can be scrutinised.
- Diversity deficit: women hold roughly 14% of High Court judgeships, and representation of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and OBCs in the higher judiciary remains far below population share.
- Delay: recommendations can sit with the Government for months without formal rejection, giving the executive a de-facto pocket veto that the system was designed to prevent.
- Absence of a permanent secretariat means the collegium has no institutional capacity to independently assess candidates beyond personal knowledge and circulated reports.
The Defence
- Judicial independence is basic structure, and the primacy of the judiciary in its own appointments is the mechanism the Court has held necessary to protect it.
- Executive-dominated models risk appointments turning on political alignment, especially where the Government is the largest single litigant.
- The Memorandum of Procedure, if finalised and honoured, could deliver transparency without transferring primacy back to the executive.
Way Forward
- Finalise the long-pending Memorandum of Procedure with published, objective eligibility criteria and reasoned records for recommendations.
- Establish a permanent secretariat with a searchable, merit-based database of eligible advocates and district judges to widen the candidate pool beyond informal networks.
- Set enforceable timelines for the Government to act on reiterated recommendations.
- Adopt transparent diversity targets, particularly for women and for elevation from the district judiciary.
Exam Angle — Prelims & Mains
- UPSC PYQ Link (Mains 2022, GS Paper 2): "Discuss the desirability of greater representation to women in the higher judiciary to ensure diversity, equity and inclusiveness." — The 14% figure and the collegium's opacity are the two facts that anchor a strong answer here.
- Practice Mains Question (GS Paper 2, 15 marks, 250 words): "The collegium system protects judicial independence at the cost of transparency and diversity." Critically examine, and suggest reforms that could reconcile the two objectives.
- Prelims Angle: The Three Judges Cases sequence (1981, 1993, 1998) and the striking down of the 99th Amendment and NJAC Act in 2015 are frequently tested; note also that the collegium appears nowhere in the constitutional text.
- Practice Prelims MCQ: With reference to the appointment of judges to the higher judiciary in India, consider the following statements:1. The collegium system is expressly provided for in Article 124 of the Constitution.2. The Third Judges Case (1998) arose out of a Presidential Reference and expanded the Supreme Court collegium to the Chief Justice of India and four senior-most judges.3. The National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014 and the 99th Constitutional Amendment were struck down by the Supreme Court in 2015.Which of the statements given above is/are correct?Options:(A) 1 and 2 only(B) 2 and 3 only(C) 1 and 3 only(D) 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: (B) 2 and 3 only — Statement 1 is INCORRECT: Article 124 refers only to appointment by the President after "consultation"; the collegium is a judicial interpretation of that word, not a textual provision. Statements 2 and 3 are correct.
- Practice Prelims MCQ: With reference to the appointment of judges to the higher judiciary in India, consider the following statements: