A step forward in Jamia, a long road ahead — UPSC Editorial Analysis
The editorial argues that restoring student union elections at Jamia Millia Islamia after a long hiatus, spurred by student protests, is a positive step towards greater student participation and accountability. It highlights the broader trend of reintroducing student polls in various states, suggesting a shift away from outright bans towards regulated elections.
SyllabusGovernment policies and interventions for the development of education sector.
UPSC analysis
GS Paper 2Context
- Student union elections have been suspended in many Indian universities for years, often citing concerns about politicisation and violence.
- The Lyngdoh Committee (2005) made recommendations to reform student elections, which some institutions interpreted as a basis for discontinuing them.
- Student activism and protests have historically played a role in shaping campus policies and addressing broader societal issues.
- Recent student-led movements and state-level actions indicate a growing momentum for the revival of student elections.
Key issues
- The long suspension of student union elections at Jamia Millia Islamia, ending only after a student hunger strike, points to administrative intransigence.
- The use of spectres of politicisation and disruption as justifications for banning student elections is a flawed approach.
- The absence of elections has led to a 'breakdown of trust' and 'infantilisation' of young adults by limiting their decision-making roles.
- Student unions have historically been platforms for intellectual and political consciousness, connecting campus issues to larger societal representation and citizenship concerns.
- Student dissent on campuses, such as the response to the Citizenship Amendment Act protests, has sometimes led to punitive measures against students.
The other side
- Concerns about money, muscle power, and undue external political influence in student elections are legitimate and were acknowledged by the Lyngdoh Committee.
- The potential for campus disruption and violence, if not properly managed, can negatively impact academic environments.
Way forward
- Universities should implement the recommendations of the Lyngdoh Committee to ensure transparency and accountability in student elections, rather than abolishing them.
- Administrations should foster open communication and trust with students, avoiding repressive disciplinary actions and restrictions.
- A clear framework and time-bound commitments are needed for the conduct of elections, as demonstrated by Jamia's recent commitment.
- States should continue to explore mechanisms for the safe and effective revival of student polls, learning from diverse approaches like judicial intervention and committee formations.
Key terms
| Lyngdoh Committee | A committee formed in 2005 to recommend reforms for student union elections in Indian universities. |
| Infantilisation of young adults | Treating young adults as if they are less mature or capable than they are, by limiting their agency and decision-making opportunities. |
| Spectres of politicisation | The invocation of fears and anxieties about political interference and negative influences in student elections. |
Prelims facts
- The Lyngdoh Committee was constituted in 2005.
- Jamia Millia Islamia had suspended student union elections for nearly two decades.
Mains practice question
Examine the rationale behind the suspension of student union elections in Indian universities and discuss the implications of their revival for campus democracy, student engagement, and institutional governance.
Prelims practice MCQ
Which committee's recommendations are often cited in discussions regarding reforms or discontinuation of student union elections in Indian universities?
- Sachar Committee
- Lyngdoh Committee
- Kothari Commission
- Mehta Committee
Show answerHide answer
The Lyngdoh Committee, constituted in 2005, made significant recommendations concerning student elections, which have been a focal point in debates about their conduct and continuation.
More editorials from 2 November 2026
EdiShorts' own UPSC analysis of the editorial, written with AI assistance and automatically checked to contain no text from the original. Headlines belong to their publications; read the full editorial at the source.