Why in News: Former Supreme Court judge Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul’s forthcoming memoir, “Without Fear or Favour”, reported in late October 2026, alleges that former Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud considered checking the government’s view on a candidate before the collegium had deliberated, and that informal “pre-approval” consultation with the executive became a pattern after the NJAC judgment. Justice Kaul distinguished consultation (which the system allows) from pre-approval (which, he argued, undermines judicial primacy). Justice Chandrachud’s side has said the government has a legitimate role in a consultative process.
Key Issues Raised
- Pre-clearance vs consultation: the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) envisages the executive’s inputs after the collegium recommends, not a veto before it deliberates.
- Short tenures of Chief Justices make it hard to reverse practices once they settle.
- Selective delays: the government has at times sat on or “segregated” names in collegium lists, accepting some and returning others — a recurring complaint from the Supreme Court.
- Diversity: the memoir also refers to the government’s objection to an openly gay candidate — a debate that came out in 2023.
Arguments For and Against the Collegium
- For: independence of the judiciary (part of the basic structure); insulation from political patronage; the NJAC model gave the executive and “eminent persons” an effective veto.
- Against: opacity — no published criteria or reasons; “judges appointing judges” is unknown to most democracies; under-representation of women, SC/ST/OBC and first-generation lawyers; vacancies (High Courts often run with 30%+ vacancies).
Way Forward
- Finalise the revised MoP with written criteria, a secretariat and timelines for both the collegium and the government.
- Publish reasons for recommendations (as briefly attempted from 2017) and for the government’s returns.
- A time limit after which a reiterated recommendation is deemed accepted, as the Supreme Court has urged.
- Wider consultation pools — Bar, retired judges — and a diversity commitment.
Static Background — Appointment of Judges
- Article 124(2): Supreme Court judges are appointed by the President after consultation with such judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts as the President deems necessary; the CJI must always be consulted for appointing other judges.
- Article 217: High Court judges appointed by the President after consulting the CJI, the Governor and the Chief Justice of that High Court. Article 222: transfer of HC judges. Article 224A: retired judges sitting as ad hoc judges in High Courts.
- The Judges Cases:
- First (S.P. Gupta, 1981): “consultation” does not mean “concurrence” — executive primacy.
- Second (SC Advocates-on-Record Association, 1993): judicial primacy; the collegium of the CJI and two senior-most judges.
- Third (Presidential reference, 1998): the collegium enlarged to the CJI and four senior-most judges for SC appointments.
- Fourth (SCAORA, 2015): the 99th Amendment and the NJAC Act, 2014 struck down by 4:1 (Justice Chelameswar dissenting) for violating judicial independence.
- NJAC composition (struck down): CJI, two senior-most SC judges, the Union Law Minister and two eminent persons — any two could veto a name.
- Appointments of the CJI follow the seniority convention; the Memorandum of Procedure dates from 1999.
| Case | Year | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| S.P. Gupta (First Judges) | 1981 | Executive primacy |
| SCAORA (Second Judges) | 1993 | Collegium created, judicial primacy |
| Third Judges (Reference) | 1998 | Collegium: CJI + 4 senior-most judges |
| NJAC (Fourth Judges) | 2015 | 99th Amendment struck down |
Exam Angle — Prelims & Mains
- UPSC PYQ Link (Mains 2025, GS Paper 2): Discuss the evolution of the collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.
- Practice Mains Question (GS Paper 2, 15 marks, 250 words): “The collegium has secured independence at the cost of transparency.” In the light of recent disclosures by former judges, suggest reforms that preserve judicial primacy while improving accountability.
- Prelims Angle: the Judges Cases and the articles on appointment and transfer.
- Practice Prelims MCQ 1: Consider the following pairs:1. First Judges Case — consultation does not mean concurrence2. Second Judges Case — collegium of CJI and four senior-most judges3. Fourth Judges Case — National Judicial Appointments Commission struck downWhich of the pairs given above are correctly matched?(A) 1 and 2 only(B) 2 and 3 only(C) 1 and 3 only(D) 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: (C) 1 and 3 only — Statement 1 is CORRECT — S.P. Gupta (1981). Statement 2 is INCORRECT — the Second Judges Case (1993) created a collegium of the CJI and two senior-most judges; it was enlarged to four in the Third Judges Case (1998). Statement 3 is CORRECT — the 2015 judgment. - Practice Prelims MCQ 2: Under which Article of the Constitution can a retired judge be requested to sit and act as a judge of a High Court?(A) Article 217(B) Article 222(C) Article 224(D) Article 224A
Show answer
Answer: (D) — Article 224A provides for retired judges at sittings of High Courts. Article 217 deals with appointment, Article 222 with transfer and Article 224 with additional and acting judges.
- Practice Prelims MCQ 1: Consider the following pairs: