Why in News: The October 2026 protests over the SIR of electoral rolls tested the limits of the right to protest in the national capital. Delhi Police invoked Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), detained thousands, closed metro stations and denotified Jantar Mantar as a protest site. The Supreme Court ruled out a blanket closure of metro and rail services (9 October), directed that suitable alternative protest sites be designated, and ordered the Centre and Delhi Police to prevent unlawful detentions.
Key Developments
- Section 163 BNSS (the successor of Section 144 CrPC) was imposed in New Delhi district before the planned protests; overnight “preventive” detentions were made.
- Transport restrictions: on 10 October about 45 metro stations were shut, mobile internet was restricted in parts of central Delhi and over 200 trains were cancelled or rescheduled; these were lifted after the Supreme Court’s intervention.
- Jantar Mantar was denotified; Ramlila Maidan, the CBD Ground and Burari Ground were named as alternatives.
- Peace bonds: protesters were asked to execute bonds (security for keeping the peace) and some were sent to judicial custody; a special bench refused immediate relief in habeas petitions on 11 October but noted a prima facie case.
- Overseas Citizens of India who joined protests reportedly received “leave India” notices.
- International reaction: the UN human rights office expressed concern; India rejected it as interference in internal matters.
The Constitutional Position
- Article 19(1)(b) guarantees the right “to assemble peaceably and without arms”; Article 19(1)(a) protects expression, of which protest is a form.
- Article 19(3) allows only reasonable restrictions in the interests of the sovereignty and integrity of India or public order — so every restriction must be proportionate and tied to a real threat to public order.
- Article 22 safeguards arrested and detained persons: to be told the grounds, to consult a lawyer, and to be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours.
How the Courts Have Drawn the Line
- Babulal Parate v. State of Maharashtra (1961) and Madhu Limaye (1970): upheld Section 144 CrPC as a preventive power, but only for an emergency and subject to judicial review.
- Himat Lal K. Shah v. Commissioner of Police (1972): the State may regulate assemblies on public streets but cannot use regulation to prohibit them; if streets and parks could be closed entirely, open-air meetings in a large city would become impossible.
- Ramlila Maidan Incident (2012): the midnight eviction of sleeping protesters was held to be an excessive use of force.
- Anita Thakur v. State of J&K (2016): police excess against peaceful protesters violates Article 21 and deserves compensation.
- Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India (2018): a total ban on protests at Jantar Mantar and the Boat Club was struck down; guidelines for regulated use were ordered.
- Amit Sahni v. Commissioner of Police (2020, Shaheen Bagh): public ways cannot be occupied indefinitely; protest must be at designated sites.
- Anuradha Bhasin (2020): internet shutdowns must be necessary, proportionate and reviewed.
Issues Raised
- Pre-emptive bans: blanket orders issued before any assembly invert the rule that restriction is the exception.
- Chilling effect: mass detentions, bonds and deportation notices deter lawful dissent.
- Collateral restrictions: shutting transport and the internet affects lakhs of non-protesters and needs a separate proportionality test.
- Policing: bodycams and lawyer access improve accountability, but undisclosed detentions undermine Article 22.
Way Forward
- Treat notification of protest sites as a matter of course, with transparent, time-bound permission and appeal procedures.
- Use Section 163 orders only on specific intelligence, for limited areas and durations, with reasons published.
- Follow the proportionality standard (Modern Dental College, 2016; Puttaswamy, 2017) for transport and internet restrictions.
- Strengthen independent police complaints authorities (Prakash Singh, 2006) and record crowd-control actions on camera.
Static Background — Law on Assemblies and Public Order
- Old and new laws: Section 144 CrPC → Section 163 BNSS (urgent orders in nuisance or apprehended danger, normally up to two months, extendable to six by the State); dispersal of unlawful assemblies: Sections 129–131 CrPC → Sections 148–150 BNSS; security for keeping the peace: Section 107 CrPC → Section 126 BNSS; unlawful assembly as an offence: Section 141 IPC → Section 189 BNS.
- An unlawful assembly is an assembly of five or more persons with a common object such as overawing the government by criminal force, resisting the law, or committing mischief.
- Public order vs law and order: Ram Manohar Lohia (1966) explained the three concentric circles — law and order (widest), public order, and security of the State (narrowest); Article 19(3) permits restriction only for public order, not mere law and order.
- Police and public order are State List subjects (Entries 1 and 2, List II); Delhi Police reports to the Union Home Ministry.
- OCI cardholders: Section 7D of the Citizenship Act, 1955 allows cancellation of OCI registration on specified grounds, including acting against the sovereignty and integrity of India.
| Provision (old → new) | Subject |
|---|---|
| Sec 144 CrPC → Sec 163 BNSS | Prohibitory orders in urgent cases |
| Secs 129–131 CrPC → Secs 148–150 BNSS | Dispersal of unlawful assembly |
| Sec 107 CrPC → Sec 126 BNSS | Security bond for keeping the peace |
| Sec 141 IPC → Sec 189 BNS | Definition of unlawful assembly |
Exam Angle — Prelims & Mains
- UPSC PYQ Link: No past UPSC question is directly on the right to protest; the topic links to Mains GS-2 themes on fundamental rights and reasonable restrictions.
- Practice Mains Question (GS Paper 2, 15 marks, 250 words): “Reasonable regulation of protest is different from prohibition.” Discuss with reference to Section 163 of the BNSS and the Supreme Court’s rulings on the right to peaceful assembly.
- Prelims Angle: the grounds in Article 19(3) for restricting assembly and the new-law section numbers are favourite traps.
- Practice Prelims MCQ 1: The right to assemble peaceably and without arms under Article 19(1)(b) can be restricted by law in the interests of which of the following?1. Sovereignty and integrity of India2. Public order3. Friendly relations with foreign States4. Decency or moralitySelect the correct answer using the code given below:(A) 1 and 2 only(B) 2 and 3 only(C) 1, 3 and 4 only(D) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Show answer
Answer: (A) 1 and 2 only — Statement 1 is CORRECT and Statement 2 is CORRECT — Article 19(3) lists only these two grounds for the right to assemble. Statement 3 is INCORRECT and Statement 4 is INCORRECT — friendly relations, decency and morality are grounds under Article 19(2) for restricting speech, not assembly. - Practice Prelims MCQ 2: Consider the following pairs:1. Prohibitory order in urgent cases — Section 163, BNSS2. Security for keeping the peace — Section 126, BNSS3. Definition of unlawful assembly — Section 189, BNSHow many of the pairs given above are correctly matched?(A) Only one(B) Only two(C) All three(D) None
Show answer
Answer: (C) All three — Section 163 BNSS replaces Section 144 CrPC; Section 126 BNSS replaces Section 107 CrPC; Section 189 BNS replaces Section 141 IPC. - Practice Prelims MCQ 3: In which case did the Supreme Court strike down a complete ban on protests at Jantar Mantar and the Boat Club in New Delhi?(A) Amit Sahni v. Commissioner of Police(B) Anita Thakur v. State of Jammu and Kashmir(C) Himat Lal K. Shah v. Commissioner of Police(D) Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India
Show answer
Answer: (D) — In 2018 the Court held a total ban disproportionate and ordered guidelines for regulated protests. Amit Sahni (2020) concerned Shaheen Bagh; Himat Lal (1972) dealt with rules on public meetings; Anita Thakur (2016) concerned police excess.
- Practice Prelims MCQ 1: The right to assemble peaceably and without arms under Article 19(1)(b) can be restricted by law in the interests of which of the following?