EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2007EssayTopic 2 · 200 marksModel answer

Evaluation of Panchayati Raj System in India from the point of view of eradication of power to people.

DirectiveEssay
Marks200
Word limit1800–2000
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1800–2000 words, 200 marks; write one essay from the six topics. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular verdict. An 'evaluation' asks for a balanced assessment: how far Panchayati Raj has actually transferred power to the people since the 73rd Amendment, judged by funds, functions, functionaries and participation. ('Eradication' in the printed topic is read as 'devolution/transfer' of power.)

Common trap: Weak essays describe the 73rd Amendment's provisions. The top essay of 2007 evaluates: it credits elected bodies everywhere, regular elections and lakhs of women and SC/ST representatives, then shows the gap between constitutional form and real devolution — the '3Fs', state control, elite capture, weak gram sabhas — using Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, MKSS social audits and NREGA as evidence, and ends with a measured verdict.

Essay brief

1800–2000 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Constitutional reading: the 73rd Amendment created a third tier with mandatory elections, reservation and finance commissions — a historic transfer in form.
  • Substantive reading: power to the people depends on states devolving funds, functions and functionaries; most have not, so devolution is partial (strongest reading).
  • Social reading: reservation brought women, Dalits and tribals into local power — but caste, patriarchy and proxies limit their real authority.
  • Participatory reading: the gram sabha is the true seat of people's power; where it works (Kerala, social audits), democracy deepens.
Dimensions to cover

The journey

  • Article 40 directive; Balwantray Mehta Committee (1957) three-tier model; Ashok Mehta Committee (1978)
  • L. M. Singhvi Committee (1986) urged constitutional status
  • 73rd Amendment (1992, in force 24 April 1993): Part IX, Articles 243–243O; Eleventh Schedule with 29 subjects

Achievements

  • Regular elections under State Election Commissions; about 30 lakh elected representatives
  • One-third seats for women (Bihar raised it to 50% in 2006); SC/ST reservation
  • PESA (1996) for Fifth Schedule areas recognising gram sabha control over resources
  • Ministry of Panchayati Raj set up in 2004 to push devolution

The 3Fs gap

  • Funds: heavy dependence on tied state and central grants; little own revenue
  • Functions: many of the 29 subjects devolved only on paper
  • Functionaries: staff remain under state departments, not panchayats
  • State Finance Commission reports often ignored

Social realities

  • Proxy 'sarpanch-pati' and elite capture by dominant castes
  • Bureaucratic control through collectors and BDOs; no-confidence and suspension powers misused
  • Parallel bodies and MP/MLA Local Area Development funds bypassing panchayats

Where it works

  • Kerala's People's Plan Campaign (1996): about a third of plan funds to local bodies with gram sabha planning
  • Madhya Pradesh's gram swaraj experiments
  • MKSS (Rajasthan) public hearings and social audits; Right to Information Act, 2005
  • NREGA (2005) places panchayats at the centre of planning and implementation

Way forward

  • Activity mapping to clarify which tier does what
  • Untied funds and own revenue; capacity building of elected members
  • Strengthen gram sabhas and social audit
  • Transparent devolution index to rank states
Structure

Opening. Open with Gandhi's dream of every village a republic, and the reality of 2007: India now has the world's largest number of elected representatives — but does the sarpanch control the school, the well and the budget?

Body. Trace the journey to the 73rd Amendment; record the achievements; then evaluate devolution through funds, functions, functionaries; then social realities; then successes.

Counter-view. Acknowledge the argument that panchayats are captured by local elites and that centralised delivery is cleaner — and answer that the cure for bad local democracy is better local democracy.

Conclusion. Verdict: Panchayati Raj has transferred presence and voice but not yet power; the next step is real devolution of the 3Fs and a strong gram sabha. (Later: many states raised women's reservation to 50%; Fourteenth and Fifteenth Finance Commissions gave larger direct grants to panchayats.)

Examples to use
  • 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992 — Constitutional third tier
  • Balwantray Mehta (1957), Ashok Mehta (1978) and L. M. Singhvi (1986) committees — Evolution of the idea
  • Kerala People's Plan Campaign (1996) — Model of fiscal devolution and participatory planning
  • Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan's jan sunwais (Rajasthan) — Social audit as people's power
  • PESA Act, 1996 — Gram sabha powers in tribal areas
  • Bihar's 50% reservation for women in panchayats (2006) — Deepening representation
  • NREGA (2005) — Panchayats as implementing agencies
Quotes
  • “True democracy cannot be worked by twenty men sitting at the centre. It has to be worked from below by the people of every village.” — Mahatma Gandhi
Pitfalls
  • Describing provisions without evaluating them
  • Ignoring the 3Fs — funds, functions, functionaries
  • Treating the printed word 'eradication' literally without explaining the reading
  • Ignoring successful states

More from Essay 2007

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.