What are the alternative fuels available for the transport sector? Discuss their characteristics, advantages and disadvantages in their utilization.
Identify the main alternative transport fuels and compare their characteristics, advantages and disadvantages, with India's experience.
Common trap: Do not stop at a list. A good answer compares each fuel on the three asked dimensions (a table works well) and cites Indian cases such as Delhi's CNG switch, ethanol blending and the jatropha biodiesel mission.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): Developments in Science and Technology — energy and its applications.
Model answer
15 marks · 150-word limitTransport depends almost wholly on petrol and diesel, most of it imported, and is a leading source of urban air pollution. Alternative fuels can improve energy security and cut emissions; India has tried several since the Supreme Court ordered Delhi's public transport to switch to CNG in the M.C. Mehta case.
- CNG and auto-LPG
- Ethanol blending
- Biodiesel (jatropha)
- Hydrogen and fuel cells
- Battery electric vehicles
Characteristics, advantages and disadvantages
| Fuel | Characteristics | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|---|
| CNG | Methane compressed to about 200 bar | Very low particulates and sulphur, cheaper per km | Bulky cylinders, few stations, needs pipeline gas |
| Auto-LPG | Propane-butane, liquefied under low pressure | Cleaner than petrol, easy retrofit | Mostly imported, safety risks of illegal kits |
| Ethanol | Alcohol from sugarcane molasses, blended with petrol | Renewable, helps sugar farmers, cuts carbon monoxide | Supply tied to sugar cycle; food–fuel and water concerns |
| Biodiesel | Esters from non-edible oils like jatropha and pongamia | Biodegradable, sulphur-free, grows on wasteland | Low seed yields, high cost, slow plantation progress |
| Hydrogen | Burned or used in fuel cells, emits only water | Zero tailpipe emissions, high energy per kg | Costly production, storage and safety; no infrastructure |
| Electric | Battery-powered motors | No tailpipe emissions, quiet, efficient | Costly batteries, short range, coal-based power |
Indian experience
- CNG: Delhi's buses, autos and taxis moved to CNG in the early 2000s, improving air quality; Mumbai and other cities followed.
- Biofuels: 5% ethanol blending was mandated in nine states from 2003, and a National Mission on Biodiesel based on jatropha was proposed in 2003.
- Future fuels: The 2006 Hydrogen Energy Road Map and small electric cars like the Reva show interest, but costs remain high.
No single fuel can replace petroleum soon; a mix — CNG in cities, biofuels from non-food sources and long-term research on hydrogen and batteries — together with efficient public transport is the realistic path to cleaner, more secure mobility.
Read more — sources
- OfficialPlanning Commission, Report of the Committee on Development of Bio-fuel (2003)
- OfficialMinistry of New and Renewable Energy, National Hydrogen Energy Road Map (2006)
- ReportAuto Fuel Policy Report (Mashelkar Committee), 2002
More from GS Paper II (old) 2007
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.