EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2011EssayTopic 1 · 200 marksModel answer

Creation of smaller states and the consequent administrative, economic and developmental implications.

DirectiveEssay
Marks200
Word limit1800–2000
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1800–2000 words, 200 marks. In the old pattern (2011) the candidate wrote ONE essay chosen from four topics. Graded on understanding of the topic, orderly arrangement of ideas and concise expression. A topic that names its own structure: cover the creation of smaller states and then each implication — administrative, economic, developmental — with the 2000 states as evidence.

Common trap: Weak essays either cheer every statehood demand or warn of 'balkanisation'. The top essay of 2011 places the Telangana agitation and the Srikrishna Committee (December 2010) in the history from the States Reorganisation Commission (1955) and Ambedkar's case for dividing large states, uses the record of Uttarakhand, Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand (2000) as evidence, and argues that size alone does not decide good governance.

Essay brief

1800–2000 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Administrative reading: smaller states bring government closer to people, improve span of control and give neglected regions a voice.
  • Economic reading: new states can attract investment and grow faster, but also face revenue loss, disputes over water, capital and assets, and dependence on central transfers.
  • Developmental reading: the test is whether human development improves for all, not just whether a new elite gains power (strongest reading, with the 2000 states as evidence).
  • Political reading: statehood demands reflect identity and regional neglect; the real question is the criteria and process the Union should follow under Article 3.
Dimensions to cover

Background: how India's map has changed

  • Linguistic reorganisation after Potti Sriramulu's death (1952) and the States Reorganisation Commission (Fazl Ali, 1955); States Reorganisation Act, 1956
  • Later states: Maharashtra and Gujarat (1960), Nagaland (1963), Haryana (1966), north-eastern states (1972, 1987), Goa (1987)
  • Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand created in November 2000 on grounds of administrative and developmental neglect
  • Article 3 gives Parliament the power to form new states by simple majority after referring the Bill to the state legislature for its views

Live demands in 2011

  • Telangana: the Union's statement of 9 December 2009, the Srikrishna Committee report (December 2010) with six options, continuing agitation in 2011
  • Gorkhaland in Darjeeling: a tripartite agreement for a Gorkhaland Territorial Administration was signed in July 2011
  • Vidarbha, Bundelkhand, Harit Pradesh and other proposals to split Uttar Pradesh
  • Calls for a second States Reorganisation Commission to set objective criteria

Administrative implications

  • Closer, more responsive government and a shorter distance to the capital
  • Better span of control for the bureaucracy and police; Ambedkar argued in 'Thoughts on Linguistic States' (1955) for dividing very large states
  • Costs: new capitals, secretariats, high courts and cadres; shortage of trained officers at the start
  • Risk of political instability in small assemblies — Jharkhand saw repeated changes of government and President's Rule

Economic implications

  • Uttarakhand and Chhattisgarh grew faster after 2000 than their parent states, helped by focused policies and central incentives
  • Disputes over sharing water, power, debt, assets and civil servants with the parent state
  • Revenue imbalance: a new state may lose a capital city or industrial base (the Hyderabad question in Telangana)
  • Mineral-rich Jharkhand shows growth can coexist with corruption and poor governance

Developmental implications

  • Focused attention to backward regions, tribal communities and hill areas
  • Development depends on governance quality rather than size — compare Himachal Pradesh's success with Jharkhand's struggles
  • Risk that new regional elites capture benefits while sub-regions inside the new state still feel neglected
  • Federal balance: more states can strengthen cooperative federalism or fragment bargaining power

Criteria for the future

  • Administrative viability, economic self-reliance and a consensus of the people, not agitation alone
  • A standing or second States Reorganisation Commission to examine demands objectively
  • Alternatives: regional development boards (Article 371), autonomous councils (Sixth Schedule), decentralisation to panchayats and districts
  • Fair settlement of water, assets, capital and the rights of migrants
Structure

Opening. Open with November 2000, when three new states were born without bloodshed, and contrast it with the Telangana agitation of 2009–11 — asking why some new states succeed and what the country should learn before drawing new lines.

Body. Trace reorganisation from 1956 to 2000; describe current demands; then take each implication in turn — administrative, economic, developmental — with evidence from the three 2000 states.

Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the fears: balkanisation, identity politics, small-state instability and the cost of new capitals — and answer them with the record of states that have done well.

Conclusion. Conclude that size is a means, not an end: smaller states help where they bring better governance and consent, and an objective commission and real decentralisation should guide the next steps. (Later: in November 2011 the Uttar Pradesh Assembly passed a resolution to split the state into four; Telangana became India's 29th state on 2 June 2014.)

Examples to use
  • States Reorganisation Commission (Fazl Ali, 1955) and Act of 1956 — Linguistic basis of the first reorganisation
  • Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand (2000) — Test cases of smaller-state performance
  • Srikrishna Committee on Telangana (December 2010) — Options and difficulties of a new state
  • Gorkhaland Territorial Administration agreement (July 2011) — Autonomy as an alternative to statehood
  • B. R. Ambedkar, 'Thoughts on Linguistic States' (1955) — Case for dividing very large states
  • Himachal Pradesh's human development record — A small state that governed well
  • Article 3 and Article 371 of the Constitution — Constitutional process and regional boards
Quotes
  • “India is an indestructible Union of destructible States.” — Common description of Indian federalism (cited by the Supreme Court)
Pitfalls
  • Discussing only Telangana and ignoring the general question
  • Assuming smaller states automatically mean better development
  • Skipping one of the three named implications
  • Ignoring alternatives such as autonomous councils and decentralisation

More from Essay 2011

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.