Comment on: Benefits and potential drawbacks of 'cash-transfers' to 'Below Poverty Line' (BPL) households.
Weigh the advantages of replacing in-kind subsidies with cash against its risks for poor households, and give a view.
Common trap: Answers that are only for or against lose marks. A strong answer cites the 2011 Nilekani Task Force and Aadhaar, Latin American conditional cash transfers, and balances leakage reduction against food-security and exclusion concerns.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper I (2006–12): Current national issues — poverty, food security and welfare delivery
Model answer
12 marks · 150-word limitIn 2011 the government considered replacing subsidised kerosene, LPG, fertiliser and possibly food with direct cash transfers to BPL households, using bank accounts and the Aadhaar number. The Nilekani Task Force on Direct Transfer of Subsidies outlined the method.
- Less leakage, fewer middlemen
- Choice for households
- Financial inclusion
- Lower handling costs
- Inflation erodes value
- Banks and markets far away
- Exclusion in BPL lists
- Food security at risk
Benefits
- Plugging leakages: Studies showed large diversion of PDS grain and kerosene; cash paid into accounts reduces middlemen and fake ration cards.
- Choice and dignity: Households can decide their own consumption, and Brazil's Bolsa Familia and Mexico's Oportunidades show cash can improve health and schooling.
- Efficiency: It cuts storage and transport costs and frees the market from price distortions.
Potential drawbacks
- Price risk: Fixed cash loses value in inflation, unlike a fixed grain entitlement.
- Access: Bank branches and functioning markets are distant in tribal and remote areas.
- Targeting: BPL lists have large exclusion errors, so cash does not fix the core targeting problem.
- Intra-household use: Cash may be spent on non-essentials unless paid to women.
- Food economy: Weakening the PDS could undermine procurement and minimum support prices for farmers.
Cash transfers suit fuel and fertiliser subsidies sooner than food. A phased, evidence-based approach with Aadhaar-linked accounts, transfers to women and indexed amounts is wise. (Later: Direct Benefit Transfer began in January 2013.)
Read more — sources
- ReportTask Force on Direct Transfer of Subsidies on Kerosene, LPG and Fertiliser (Chairman Nandan Nilekani), 2011
- OfficialEconomic Survey 2010–11 — subsidies and delivery
- BookJean Drèze and Reetika Khera, writings on PDS reform in EPW
More from GS Paper I (old) 2011
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.