Managing work and home — is the Indian working woman getting a fair deal?
1800–2000 words, 200 marks. In the old pattern (2012) the candidate wrote ONE essay chosen from four topics. Graded on understanding of the topic, orderly arrangement of ideas and concise expression. A question topic: examine the 'double burden' at home and at work, weigh the progress made, and answer 'not yet a fair deal' with reasons and remedies.
Common trap: Weak essays praise a few women CEOs or describe women as suffering victims. The top essay sees the whole range — the informal-sector worker who is most Indian working women, the salaried professional — and analyses the fairness of the deal at home (unpaid care work, unequal sharing), at work (wage gap, harassment, maternity penalty, glass ceiling) and in the state's support (laws, crèches, safety), ending with a balanced 'improving but not fair yet' and concrete reforms that make men and institutions share the load.
Essay brief
1800–2000 words · 125 marks- Economic reading: women earn less, are concentrated in informal work and carry most unpaid care work — the deal is unfair.
- Social reading: patriarchal expectations make the home 'her' responsibility even when she earns, producing a double burden.
- Institutional reading: laws exist, but workplaces, transport and childcare are not designed for women who also run homes.
- Balanced reading: the deal is improving for some urban professionals but is far from fair for most working women, and fairness requires change at home, at work and in the state (strongest reading).
Who is the Indian working woman?
- Most work in agriculture, construction, domestic work and home-based industry — the informal sector
- A growing urban middle class of salaried professionals in IT, banking, teaching, health and government
- Female labour-force participation is low and fell in NSSO's 2009–10 survey, partly due to more girls in education
The deal at home
- Unpaid care work — cooking, child and elder care — falls overwhelmingly on women
- The 'second shift': paid work does not reduce household duties
- Guilt and social judgement over 'neglecting' children or in-laws
- Rising nuclear families remove the joint-family support for childcare
The deal at work
- Gender wage gap despite the Equal Remuneration Act (1976)
- Sexual harassment: Vishaka guidelines (1997); a Bill on workplace harassment passed by the Lok Sabha in 2012
- Maternity penalty — 12 weeks of leave under the Maternity Benefit Act (1961) and loss of promotion after breaks
- Glass ceiling: few women on boards and in senior management; few crèches at worksites
Signs of progress
- Women leaders — Indra Nooyi, Chanda Kochhar, Kiran Mazumdar-Shaw — as role models
- 730 days of child care leave for central government women employees (Sixth Pay Commission, 2008)
- Self-help groups and MGNREGA (one-third reservation for women) giving rural women income
- Women's reservation in panchayats (raised to 50% in many states) building confidence
Counter-view
- Many women choose flexible or part-time work and value family roles
- Urban families increasingly share work; younger men are more involved
- Some protective laws (e.g. limits on night work) can themselves reduce women's employment
Making the deal fair
- Shared parenting: paternity leave, flexible hours for both parents
- Crèches, safe transport and hostels for working women
- Enforce equal pay and harassment committees; social security for informal women workers
- Change attitudes through education, media and men's participation in housework
Opening. Open with one day in the life of two women — a construction labourer carrying her infant to the site and a software engineer answering office calls while feeding her child — and ask if either is getting a fair deal.
Body. Define who the working woman is, then examine the deal at home, at work and from the state, then the signs of progress.
Counter-view. Give a paragraph to the view that choices and families are changing and many women are content — and show why structural barriers still remain.
Conclusion. Close by saying the deal is not yet fair, but fairness does not mean women doing more — it means the family, the employer and the state sharing the load.
- Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan (1997) — Guidelines against sexual harassment at the workplace
- Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Bill (passed by Lok Sabha, 2012) — Pending law to give the guidelines statutory force
- Maternity Benefit Act (1961), 12 weeks — Limited protection; (later) raised to 26 weeks in 2017
- Sixth Pay Commission child care leave (2008) — State recognising care burden — but only for mothers
- SEWA (Ela Bhatt) and Kudumbashree — Organising informal women workers
- NSSO 66th round (2009–10) — Falling female labour-force participation
- “To call woman the weaker sex is a libel; it is man's injustice to woman.” — M.K. Gandhi, Young India (1930)
- “I measure the progress of a community by the degree of progress which women have achieved.” — B.R. Ambedkar
- Writing only about urban professional women and ignoring the informal-sector majority
- Portraying women only as victims, without agency or progress
- Ignoring the role of men and the family in the 'home' half of the topic
- Citing the 2013 harassment Act or post-2012 maternity changes as already in force
More from Essay 2012
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.