"There is an urgent need for the Planning Commission to revise the chapter on health in the 12th Plan document." Comment.
Take a position on whether the draft 12th Plan health chapter needed revision, giving the specific criticisms and the counter-arguments, with reasons.
Common trap: Avoid a generic note on health problems. The strong answer contrasts the draft chapter with the High Level Expert Group (HLEG) on Universal Health Coverage, names the managed-care and low-spending concerns, and takes a clear position.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper I (2006–12): Current events of national importance and topics of social relevance
Model answer
15 marks · 150-word limitIn 2012 the draft health chapter of the 12th Plan drew criticism from public-health experts, including members of the Planning Commission's own High Level Expert Group (HLEG) on Universal Health Coverage chaired by K. Srinath Reddy, who said it diluted the Group's recommendations. The demand for revision was largely justified.
- Public spending 2.5% of GDP by 2017
- Strong public provisioning
- Free essential medicines
- Tax-funded universal coverage
- Lower spending target, under 2%
- Managed-care networks
- Greater role for private providers
- Insurance-led purchasing
Why revision was demanded
- Inadequate spending: Public health spending was only about 1% of GDP; the HLEG sought 2.5% by the end of the Plan, but the draft proposed a much smaller rise.
- Managed care: The draft proposed health care through managed-care networks purchasing services from public and private providers, which critics feared would commercialise care.
- Out-of-pocket burden: With households paying most health costs, mainly for medicines, the absence of a firm free-drugs commitment was a major gap.
- Weak primary care: Shortages of doctors and sub-centres under NRHM needed bigger public investment, not a shift to insurance.
The other side
- Fiscal limits: The Planning Commission cited fiscal constraints and argued that private capacity, already dominant, must be harnessed.
- Some gains: The draft did accept universal health coverage as a goal and expanded NRHM into a National Health Mission covering urban areas.
Revision was needed to make public financing and public provision the backbone of universal health coverage. (Later: the final Plan set public health spending at 1.87% of GDP; the National Health Policy 2017 aimed at 2.5% by 2025.)
Read more — sources
- ReportHigh Level Expert Group on Universal Health Coverage for India (chair K. Srinath Reddy), Report submitted to the Planning Commission, November 2011
- OfficialPlanning Commission, Twelfth Five Year Plan (2012–17), Vol. III, Social Sectors — Ch. 20, Health
- OfficialNational Rural Health Mission, Framework for Implementation 2005–2012
More from GS Paper I (old) 2012
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.