EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2013EssayTopic 3 · 250 marksModel answer

GDP (Gross Domestic Product) along with GDH (Gross Domestic Happiness) would be the right indices for judging the well-being of a country.

DirectiveEssay
Marks250
Word limit2200–2500
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

2200–2500 words, 250 marks. In 2013, the first year of the new Mains pattern, the candidate wrote ONE essay chosen from four topics. Graded on understanding of the topic, orderly arrangement of ideas and concise expression. A statement topic to evaluate: explain what GDP measures and misses, what a happiness index adds, and whether the two together are 'the right' indices — or still incomplete.

Common trap: Weak essays reject GDP outright or praise Bhutan uncritically. The top essay explains why GDP is necessary (jobs, revenue, poverty reduction) but blind to distribution, environment, health and unpaid work; shows what happiness measures add (Bhutan's GNH, UN resolution of 2011, World Happiness Report 2012, Stiglitz–Sen–Fitoussi 2009); notes their own problems (subjectivity, cultural bias, adaptation of the poor to deprivation); and concludes that GDP plus well-being is better, but needs capability, equity and sustainability measures too.

Essay brief

2200–2500 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Economic reading: GDP alone is a poor guide; adding happiness corrects its blind spots and the pair is a sound dashboard.
  • Philosophical reading: the purpose of the state is the good life, not output — happiness must be the end and GDP only a means.
  • Critical reading: happiness is subjective and can be manipulated; a poor person may report contentment while deprived, so happiness cannot replace hard measures.
  • Balanced reading: GDP with a happiness measure is better than GDP alone, but 'right' indices must also capture capabilities, inequality and sustainability (strongest reading).
Dimensions to cover

What GDP tells and misses

  • Measures market output; correlates with jobs, tax revenue and poverty reduction
  • Simon Kuznets himself warned (1934) that national income is not a measure of welfare
  • Blind to inequality, environmental damage, unpaid care work, leisure and health
  • India's paradox: high growth in 2003–11 alongside malnutrition the PM called a 'national shame' (HUNGaMA report, 2012)

What a happiness measure adds

  • Bhutan's Gross National Happiness (coined by the Fourth King in the 1970s) — nine domains including psychological well-being, culture, ecology and good governance
  • UN General Assembly resolution 65/309 (2011) on happiness; first World Happiness Report (2012); International Day of Happiness, 20 March (from 2013)
  • Captures trust, community, mental health and life satisfaction

Limits of happiness indices

  • Subjective and culturally variable; hard to compare across countries
  • Adaptive preferences: the deprived may report contentment (Amartya Sen's critique)
  • Bhutan's own record — the expulsion of Lhotshampa refugees in the 1990s — shows happiness rhetoric can hide exclusion
  • Risk of governments using 'happiness' to excuse low growth or poor services

Other measures of well-being

  • Human Development Index (UNDP, 1990): income, education, health
  • Stiglitz–Sen–Fitoussi Commission (2009): measure well-being and sustainability, not just output
  • OECD Better Life Index (2011); green accounting — expert group under Partha Dasgupta on green national accounts for India (2013)
  • Multidimensional Poverty Index (2010)

The Indian context (2013)

  • Growth slowing to about 4.5–5% in 2012–13, with high inflation — GDP still matters for jobs
  • Rights-based laws — MGNREGA (2005), RTE (2009), National Food Security Act (2013) — aim at well-being, not just output
  • Indian tradition values contentment (santosh) and the welfare of all (sarve bhavantu sukhinah)

Towards the right indices

  • A dashboard: growth + distribution + human development + sustainability + subjective well-being
  • Policies judged by their effect on the poorest, as Gandhi's talisman asks
  • Regular time-use, health and life-satisfaction surveys alongside national accounts
Structure

Opening. Open with Robert Kennedy's 1968 line that GDP 'measures everything except that which makes life worthwhile' — and Bhutan's King answering that Gross National Happiness matters more than Gross National Product.

Body. Explain what GDP shows and hides, what happiness adds, the limits of happiness measures, the wider family of well-being indices, and India's situation in 2013.

Counter-view. Give a paragraph to the economist's defence of GDP — growth is what lifts millions out of poverty — and to the subjectivity problem of happiness.

Conclusion. Close by saying the pair is a better compass than GDP alone, but the right test of a nation's well-being is a dashboard that also asks who gains, at what cost to nature, and with what freedom.

Examples to use
  • Bhutan's Gross National Happiness and GNH Index — National policy built on well-being
  • UN GA resolution 65/309 (2011) and World Happiness Report (2012) — Global acceptance of happiness as a policy goal
  • Stiglitz–Sen–Fitoussi Commission report (2009) — Expert case for going beyond GDP
  • UNDP Human Development Index (1990) — Earlier move from income to capability
  • HUNGaMA report on child malnutrition (2012) — Growth not translating into well-being in India
  • Easterlin paradox (1974) — Rising income without rising reported happiness
  • (Later) India ranks low in later World Happiness Reports despite fast growth — Continuing gap between GDP and well-being
Quotes
  • “The gross national product... measures everything, in short, except that which makes life worthwhile.” — Robert F. Kennedy (1968)
  • “The welfare of a nation can scarcely be inferred from a measurement of national income.” — Simon Kuznets (1934)
  • “Gross National Happiness is more important than Gross National Product.” — Jigme Singye Wangchuck, Fourth King of Bhutan
Pitfalls
  • Dismissing GDP as useless — growth still matters for a poor country
  • Uncritical praise of Bhutan's model
  • Ignoring the subjectivity and measurement problems of happiness
  • Not noting that 'GDH' is the topic's term for what is usually called Gross National Happiness

More from Essay 2013

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.