Case study: As a senior officer in the Finance Ministry, you have access to some confidential and crucial information about policy decisions that the Government is about to announce.
Identify the options open to the officer, assess each against law, confidentiality and integrity, and select one with reasons.
Common trap: The superior's closeness to the builder and the builder's good record are distractions. A top answer recognises leaking price-sensitive policy as illegal and unethical, refuses, handles the superior with tact and puts the matter on record.
SyllabusProbity in Governance: Concept of public service; Philosophical basis of governance and probity; Codes of Ethics, Codes of Conduct; challenges of corruption.
The case
As a senior officer in the Finance Ministry, you have access to some confidential and crucial information about policy decisions that the Government is about to announce. These decisions are likely to have far-reaching impact on the housing and construction industry. If the builders have access to this information beforehand, they can make huge profits. One of the builders has done a lot of quality work for the Government and is known to be close to your immediate superior, who asks you to disclose this information to the said builder.
(a) What are the options available to you?
(b) Evaluate each of these options and choose the option which you would adopt, giving reasons.
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitThe superior is asking me to leak confidential, market-sensitive information to a favoured builder. This would give one firm an unfair windfall, breach my oath and service rules, and betray public trust, however good the builder's past work may be.
- Unfair windfall to one firm
- Breach of Rule 11 and law
- Crony capitalism, loss of trust
- Level playing field for all
- Confidentiality and integrity kept
- Superior's pressure on record
(a) Options available
- Option 1: Comply with the superior and pass the information to the builder.
- Option 2: Refuse orally and keep quiet about the request.
- Option 3: Refuse, try to persuade the superior, and if he persists, put the matter in writing and report it to higher authorities or the vigilance officer.
- Option 4: Ask for a transfer or leave to avoid the situation.
(b) Evaluation
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Comply | Keeps superior pleased; career may benefit | Breach of Rule 11 and possibly the Official Secrets Act; corrupt gain to builder; distorts the market; personal liability |
| 2. Refuse quietly | Information stays protected | Superior may leak it himself through another route; no record protects me |
| 3. Refuse, persuade, record, escalate | Lawful, ethical; protects policy and self; deters misconduct | Strained relations with superior; possible adverse remarks |
| 4. Transfer or leave | Avoids immediate conflict | Escapism; leak may still happen; abdicates responsibility |
Option I would adopt: Option 3
- Tactful refusal: Explain to the superior respectfully that the information is confidential until announced, and disclosure would harm both of us and the ministry.
- Put it on record: If he insists, ask for written orders, which he is unlikely to give, and note the request in a file or a letter to the next higher authority or Chief Vigilance Officer.
- Protect the information: Limit access to the documents and maintain a record of who sees them until the announcement.
- Reasons: Policy must benefit all citizens equally; a builder's past quality work is no ground for privileged access, and confidentiality is a core duty of a civil servant.
- Fairness to the builder: The builder can compete on equal terms once the policy is public, which respects both merit and law.
Loyalty to a superior never extends to illegal acts. By refusing tactfully and placing the matter on record, the officer safeguards the integrity of policy-making and the public's faith that government decisions are not sold to insiders.
Read more — sources
- OfficialCentral Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964 — Rule 11, Communication of official information
- OfficialOfficial Secrets Act, 1923
- OfficialPrevention of Corruption Act, 1988
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2013
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.