EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2014EssayTopic 2 · 125 marksModel answer

Is the growing level of competition good for the youth?

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Declare your reading early and sustain it.

Common trap: The question invites a balanced verdict, not a yes or no. Distinguish healthy competition that builds excellence from hyper-competition that narrows learning, harms mental health and rewards privilege. A clear position by the conclusion — competition yes, but on fairer and broader terms — scores better than a fence-sitting list.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Competition as a spur: rivalry raises standards, rewards effort and prepares the young for a demanding economy.
  • Competition as a filter: where seats and jobs are scarce, competitive exams sort millions on narrow criteria, and the scarcity rather than the contest is the real problem.
  • Competition as a pressure: rising stakes produce anxiety, coaching dependence and a loss of childhood and curiosity.
  • Competition and equity: the contest is fair only if the starting line is; otherwise it amplifies inequality of class, language and region.
Dimensions to cover

The case for competition

  • Drives excellence, discipline and innovation — sport, science and enterprise all rely on it
  • Merit-based selection opened elite institutions and services to first-generation aspirants
  • Prepares youth for a globalised labour market where skills are benchmarked worldwide

Education and the exam economy

  • Hundreds of thousands appear for each seat in top entrance exams, turning learning into rank-chasing
  • A large coaching industry centred on towns like Kota converts schooling into test preparation
  • Rote preparation crowds out arts, sport, reasoning and curiosity

Psychological and social costs

  • Exam stress and fear of failure contribute to anxiety and, tragically, student suicides reported each year
  • Parental and peer comparison makes self-worth conditional on rank
  • Collaboration and empathy weaken when every classmate is a rival

Equity and access

  • Coaching costs advantage urban and affluent families; rural and vernacular-medium students start behind
  • Reservation and scholarships try to level the field but cannot fully offset unequal schooling
  • Gender norms limit girls' freedom to compete in distant cities

The economy behind the contest

  • The intensity of competition reflects a shortage of quality seats and secure jobs
  • Expanding good institutions and skilling reduces destructive scarcity
  • Entrepreneurship and diverse careers widen the definition of success

The counter-view

  • Shielding youth from competition leaves them unprepared for real life
  • Pressure can be productive; many achievers credit rigorous competition
  • Abolishing exams can make selection opaque and more open to favouritism
Structure

Opening. Open with two young people: one who discovers a gift through a science olympiad, another crushed by a third failed entrance attempt. Both are products of competition — the essay is about the difference.

Body. Give the case for competition fairly, then examine the exam economy, the mental-health costs and the equity problem, and finally trace the intensity back to scarcity of seats and jobs.

Counter-view. Concede that softening competition can breed complacency and opaque selection; the answer is better competition, not none.

Conclusion. Conclude that competition is good when it is plural, fair and humane — many paths, many measures of success, and support for those who fall. Return to the two young people.

Examples to use
  • Kota's coaching industry for engineering and medical entrance exams — The face of hyper-competition and its pressures
  • Olympiads and science talent searches (e.g. NTSE, KVPY) — Competition that discovers and nurtures talent
  • Reservation and scholarship schemes for disadvantaged groups — State efforts to equalise the starting line
  • National Education Policy 2020 proposing reduced exam stakes and multiple board attempts (later development) — Policy acknowledgment that competition needs reform
  • Startups and non-traditional careers in sport, design and media — Widening the meaning of success beyond one exam
Quotes
  • “Education is the manifestation of the perfection already in man.” — Swami Vivekananda
Pitfalls
  • Answering a simple yes or no without conditions
  • Romanticising a competition-free world or demonising all exams
  • Ignoring the structural cause — scarcity of opportunities — and blaming only parents
  • Overusing statistics you cannot verify about suicides or applicants

More from Essay 2014

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.