EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2015EssayTopic 5 · 125 marksModel answer

Technology cannot replace manpower.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Test the claim honestly: technology does replace some work; the essay should show what it cannot replace and why.

Common trap: Weak essays either fear machines or celebrate them. The top essay concedes that technology replaces many tasks — ATMs, robots — but argues that judgement, empathy, creativity and accountability remain human, that technology needs skilled people, and that for India the real question is designing technology that augments its large workforce.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Literal reading: machines cannot fully replace human labour because they need people to design, run and repair them.
  • Human-qualities reading: empathy, judgement, creativity and ethics cannot be automated (strongest reading).
  • Counter-reading: technology has replaced and will keep replacing large amounts of routine labour.
  • Indian reading: with a large young workforce, India must use technology to augment manpower, not replace it.
Dimensions to cover

What technology replaces

  • Routine physical and clerical tasks
  • Manufacturing automation and robotics
  • Banking — ATMs and internet banking

What it cannot replace

  • Care work: nurses, teachers, ASHA workers
  • Judgement: judges, administrators, doctors
  • Creativity, leadership and ethical responsibility

Technology needs manpower

  • Skilled engineers, technicians and data workers
  • Mars Orbiter Mission (2014) as human skill using technology
  • Maintenance, training and adaptation

India's situation

  • Demographic dividend needs jobs
  • Skill India (2015) and Digital India (2015)
  • Technology for inclusion: Aadhaar-based delivery, telemedicine

Counter-view

  • Industrial Revolution and Luddites: fears often proved wrong, but transitions hurt
  • Future technologies may replace even cognitive work
  • Some tasks are better done by machines — dangerous mining, manual scavenging

Way forward

  • Reskilling and lifelong learning
  • Human-centred technology design
  • Social protection during transitions
Structure

Opening. Open with an ATM next to a rural bank branch where the manager still helps an old woman fill her form — technology and manpower side by side.

Body. Concede what technology replaces, then argue what it cannot, then how technology itself depends on people, then India's demographic situation.

Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the counter-view — machines can replace dangerous and degrading work, and that is good.

Conclusion. Close with the idea that technology should amplify human capacity, not displace it — Gandhi objected to the craze for machinery, not machinery itself.

Examples to use
  • ATMs and internet banking — Technology replacing routine tasks
  • ASHA workers — Care work no machine replaces
  • Mars Orbiter Mission (2014) — Human skill behind technology
  • Mechanisation to end manual scavenging — Where replacing manpower is desirable
  • Luddites and the Industrial Revolution — Historical fears of machines
  • Skill India Mission (2015) — Preparing manpower for technology
Quotes
  • “What I object to is the craze for machinery, not machinery as such.” — Mahatma Gandhi
  • “Technology is neither good nor bad; nor is it neutral.” — Melvin Kranzberg
Pitfalls
  • Denying that technology replaces any jobs
  • Ignoring India's demographic context
  • Not distinguishing tasks from people

More from Essay 2015

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.