What was held in the Coelho case? In this context, can you say that judicial review is of key importance amongst the basic features of the Constitution?
State the holding precisely, then take and defend a position on whether judicial review is the key basic feature, weighing it against the others.
Common trap: Many answers describe the basic structure doctrine in general. A top answer states what Coelho actually held (24 April 1973 cut-off, rights and essence-of-rights tests, Articles 14, 19, 21) and then argues why judicial review is the enforcing feature without claiming it is above the others.
SyllabusIndian Constitution—historical underpinnings, evolution, features, amendments, significant provisions and basic structure.
Model answer
10 marks · 150-word limitIn I.R. Coelho v State of Tamil Nadu (11 January 2007), a nine-judge bench led by Chief Justice Y.K. Sabharwal ruled that placing a law in the Ninth Schedule under Article 31B does not put it beyond judicial review.
- 1951First Amendment adds Article 31B and Ninth Schedule
- 1973Kesavananda Bharati: basic structure doctrine (24 April)
- 1981Waman Rao: post-Kesavananda insertions open to review
- 1997L. Chandra Kumar: judicial review under Articles 32, 226 basic
- 2007I.R. Coelho: rights test for Ninth Schedule laws
What Coelho held
- Cut-off date: Laws added to the Ninth Schedule on or after 24 April 1973, the date of Kesavananda Bharati, can be tested against the basic structure.
- Rights test: Courts apply the rights test and the essence of the right test to the law's actual impact; Articles 21, 14 and 19 are part of the basic structure.
- Settled matters protected: Laws already upheld by the Supreme Court and transactions already completed were not reopened.
Why judicial review is of key importance
- The enforcing feature: Other basic features stay meaningful only because courts can strike down measures that destroy them, as in Indira Nehru Gandhi (1975) and Kihoto Hollohan (1992).
- Guard against amending power: Minerva Mills (1980) made limited amending power a basic feature; Coelho closed the Ninth Schedule route around it.
- Recent affirmation: The NJAC judgment (October 2015) struck down the 99th Amendment to protect judicial independence.
Qualifications
- Not above the others: Judicial review is the means; democracy, rule of law and rights are the ends.
- Self-restraint: Its legitimacy depends on respecting legislative policy choices.
Judicial review is therefore the keystone rather than the whole arch: without it the other basic features would rest on parliamentary goodwill. Coelho ensured that no schedule can become a constitutional black hole.
Read more — sources
- OfficialI.R. Coelho v State of Tamil Nadu, (2007) 2 SCC 1 — Supreme Court judgment, 11 January 2007
- NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 9, Constitution as a Living Document
- NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 6, Judiciary
- BookM. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity — chapter on Basic Structure of the Constitution
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2016
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.