EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2018EssayTopic 4 · 125 marksModel answer

Management of Indian border disputes — a complex task.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. A contemporary topic is graded on the balance of argument, the range of real evidence and the quality of the way forward — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Frame the problem early and keep every paragraph tied to it.

Common trap: The topic asks why the task is complex, not for a country-by-country catalogue. The trap is to write a GS-2 answer listing China, Pakistan, Nepal and Bangladesh. A top essay organises the complexity into layers — colonial legacy, terrain, ethnic communities across borders, security, water and diplomacy — and shows that India has also resolved disputes, notably with Bangladesh, which proves management is possible.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Historical reading: most of India's disputes are inherited colonial lines — McMahon, Radcliffe, Durand — drawn without regard for terrain or communities.
  • Security reading: management means preventing infiltration, smuggling and conflict along hostile, unsettled borders such as the LoC and the LAC.
  • Diplomatic reading: disputes are ultimately settled at the table, and India's record with Bangladesh shows that negotiated settlement is possible.
  • Integrated reading — the strongest: border management is complex because it is simultaneously a question of history, geography, identity, security, development and diplomacy, and no single instrument can manage it.
Dimensions to cover

Colonial and historical legacy

  • McMahon Line, Radcliffe Line and undefined stretches create rival claims
  • Partition and the Kashmir question as unresolved historical wounds
  • Shimla Agreement (1972) converting the ceasefire line into the Line of Control

Geography and terrain

  • High Himalayas, riverine borders that shift course, Sundarbans mangroves, Rann of Kutch and Sir Creek
  • Unfenceable stretches and harsh weather limit physical control
  • Undefined LAC leading to face-offs such as Doklam (2017)

People across the line

  • Ethnic and kinship ties across borders with Nepal, Myanmar and Bangladesh
  • Open India–Nepal border and the Free Movement Regime with Myanmar
  • Illegal migration, cattle and drug smuggling, and insurgent sanctuaries

Security architecture

  • Kargil Review Committee (1999) and the Group of Ministers report on border management
  • "One border, one force" principle — BSF, ITBP, SSB, Assam Rifles
  • Technology: smart fencing and integrated surveillance on sensitive stretches

Diplomacy and development

  • Land Boundary Agreement with Bangladesh (2015) and the 2014 maritime award as models
  • Border Area Development Programme to settle and develop frontier populations
  • Indus Waters Treaty (1960) showing that resource disputes can be institutionalised

The counter-view

  • Some argue disputes should simply be frozen, not managed, until power balances change
  • Over-securitisation can alienate border communities who are India's first line of defence
  • Complexity can become an excuse for inaction; Bangladesh shows political will can cut through it
Structure

Opening. Open with an image from the border — a village in the Sundarbans, a soldier on a Ladakh ridge, or the enclave residents who became citizens in 2015 — to show that borders are lived, not drawn.

Body. Organise the body by layers of complexity, not by countries: history, terrain, people, security, resources, diplomacy. Use country examples within each layer.

Counter-view. Address the view that disputes are intractable and best frozen; answer with the India–Bangladesh settlement and with the cost of neglect in border villages.

Conclusion. Close with a whole-of-government vision: secure borders, developed border villages and patient diplomacy — "borders as bridges" where possible, firm lines where necessary.

Examples to use
  • India–Bangladesh Land Boundary Agreement implemented in 2015 through the 100th Constitutional Amendment — Proof that long disputes can be resolved, including exchange of enclaves
  • Permanent Court of Arbitration award on the India–Bangladesh maritime boundary (2014) — Acceptance of third-party settlement in a maritime dispute
  • Doklam stand-off with China (2017) — The undefined LAC and trijunction complexity
  • Kargil War (1999) and the Kargil Review Committee chaired by K. Subrahmanyam — Intelligence and border management gaps leading to reform
  • Sir Creek dispute with Pakistan — A riverine and maritime dispute with economic stakes
  • Indus Waters Treaty (1960), brokered by the World Bank — Institutional management of a resource dispute between adversaries
Quotes
  • “You can change friends but not neighbours.” — Atal Bihari Vajpayee
Pitfalls
  • Writing a country-by-country GS-2 answer instead of an essay with an argument
  • Ignoring border communities and development, and seeing borders only through guns and fences
  • Giving a one-sided hawkish or dovish conclusion; the examiner rewards a calibrated mix of firmness and diplomacy

More from Essay 2018

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.