Technology as the silent factor in international relations.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. A contemporary topic is graded on the balance of argument, the range of real evidence and the quality of the way forward — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Frame the problem early and keep every paragraph tied to it.
Common trap: The key word is "silent". Weak essays list technologies. A top essay shows how technology quietly reshapes power — through industrial capacity, nuclear deterrence, cyber operations, data, semiconductors and supply chains — without the visibility of treaties and wars, and then shows technology becoming loud: tech rivalry and export controls are now openly at the centre of geopolitics. Ground examples in what was known by January 2021.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Power reading: technology silently shifts the balance of power — from gunpowder and steam to nuclear weapons and AI.
- Interdependence reading: technology networks — undersea cables, the internet, supply chains — bind states together and create new vulnerabilities.
- Rivalry reading: technology has become an arena of strategic competition — 5G, semiconductors, data and space.
- Silent-to-loud reading — the strongest: technology was long the unseen driver of IR, but it is now an explicit, contested pillar of foreign policy.
Technology and power through history
- Steam and industrial technology underpinned colonial empires
- Nuclear weapons reshaped the Cold War through deterrence
- Technology quietly determines who sets the rules
Security and warfare
- Cyber operations such as Stuxnet against Iran's nuclear programme
- Drones and precision weapons changing conflict
- Space assets — India's Mission Shakti ASAT test (2019)
Economy and supply chains
- Control over semiconductors, rare earths and critical technologies
- Data and digital platforms as sources of economic power
- Huawei and 5G restrictions in several countries
India's experience
- Technology denial after Pokhran and the push for self-reliance
- Indo-US civil nuclear deal (2008) and NSG waiver
- Entry into MTCR (2016), Wassenaar (2017) and the Australia Group (2018); ban on Chinese apps (2020)
Technology as soft power and cooperation
- India's digital public infrastructure and space diplomacy — the South Asia Satellite (2017)
- Pharmaceutical and vaccine capacity as diplomatic assets
- Global governance gaps in cyber and AI
The counter-view
- Geography, demography and ideology still shape IR
- Technology diffuses quickly, limiting lasting advantage
- Answer: technology amplifies other factors; its influence is less silent today but still often unseen
Opening. Open with the Kargil conflict of 1999, when India is widely reported to have been denied GPS data — a moment that spurred its own navigation system, NavIC — to show technology quietly shaping power.
Body. Trace technology and power historically, then security, economy and supply chains, India's experience and technology diplomacy.
Counter-view. Concede that geography, ideology and demography still matter and that technology diffuses; argue that technology is the multiplier of all other factors.
Conclusion. Close with technology moving from silent to central in IR and the need for strategic autonomy, returning to the NavIC story.
- Stuxnet cyber attack on Iran's nuclear centrifuges (around 2010) — Technology as a silent weapon
- Indo-US Civil Nuclear Agreement (2008) and the NSG waiver — Technology access reshaping diplomacy
- Mission Shakti anti-satellite test (2019) — India entering space-security club
- India's ban on Chinese apps after the Galwan clash (2020) — Technology as a tool in geopolitical rivalry
- South Asia Satellite (2017) — Technology as neighbourhood diplomacy
- Denial of GPS data during Kargil (1999) and the development of NavIC — Technology denial driving strategic self-reliance
- “War is the continuation of politics by other means.” — Carl von Clausewitz
- “Technology is neither good nor bad; nor is it neutral.” — Melvin Kranzberg
- Listing technologies without explaining how they change power relations
- Ignoring the word "silent"
- Writing only about military technology and missing economic and diplomatic dimensions
More from Essay 2020
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.