EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2022EssayTopic 8 · 125 marksModel answer

Just because you have a choice, it does not mean that any of them has to be right.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Declare your reading early and sustain it.

Common trap: Most essays drift into "make the right choice". The topic's point is harder: sometimes every available option is wrong, or less than right. The top essay explores moral dilemmas, constrained choices and the illusion of choice in markets and politics, and then asks what to do — choose the least harm, refuse the frame, or create a new option — with an honest counter-view that refusing to choose is itself a choice.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Ethical-dilemma: some situations offer only tragic choices — every option causes harm — so having choice does not guarantee a right one.
  • Structural: the options available are shaped by power; when the menu is set by others, choosing from it does not make the outcome just.
  • Consumer-democratic: abundance of options can be an illusion of freedom; more choice does not mean better choice.
  • Creative-moral (strongest): when no option is right, moral courage lies either in choosing the least harm while acknowledging the loss, or in creating a new option that the given menu excluded.
Dimensions to cover

Tragic choices

  • Arjuna at Kurukshetra — every option involved killing kin or abandoning duty
  • Triage in pandemics — scarce oxygen and ICU beds during COVID-19
  • Trolley-problem dilemmas in ethics and in self-driving car design

Choices shaped by power

  • Partition, 1947 — leaders faced options none of which avoided suffering
  • Distress migration or debt — the "choices" of poor households
  • Women "choosing" to leave work when care burdens are unshared

The illusion of choice

  • Barry Schwartz's "paradox of choice" — more options, less satisfaction
  • Markets with many brands but few owners
  • Elections where every candidate has a criminal record — NOTA (2013) as a response

Ways out of a bad menu

  • Least-harm reasoning — accepting moral residue without pretending the choice was clean
  • Gandhi's satyagraha — a third path between submission and violence
  • Innovation in policy — redesigning options rather than picking among bad ones

For public servants

  • Administrators often choose between imperfect options — eviction vs. encroachment, growth vs. ecology
  • Transparency about trade-offs builds trust
  • Ethical frameworks — consequences, duties, virtues — guide choice under uncertainty

The counter-view

  • Refusing to choose is also a choice, often the worst
  • Perfectionism can paralyse; "good enough" is often right in context
  • Relativism risk — some options are clearly better and should be chosen with confidence
Structure

Opening. Open with Arjuna on the battlefield, bow dropped, seeing that every choice before him — to fight or to flee — means a wrong done; the Gita begins precisely where the menu offers no right option.

Body. Develop tragic choices, choices shaped by power and the illusion of choice, then move to the ways out — least harm, refusal, and the creation of new options — and to what this means for public servants.

Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the objection that refusing to choose is itself a choice, and that perfectionism can be cowardice dressed as principle.

Conclusion. Conclude that freedom is not having many options but having the wisdom and courage to choose well among bad ones, or to make better ones; return to Arjuna, who acted without pretending the choice was painless.

Examples to use
  • Arjuna's dilemma in the Bhagavad Gita — Opening image of a choice with no clean option
  • Oxygen and ICU triage during the COVID-19 second wave (2021) — Contemporary tragic choice
  • PUCL v Union of India (2013) — NOTA — Institutional response when no candidate is acceptable
  • Barry Schwartz, The Paradox of Choice (2004) — More options, less freedom
  • Gandhi's satyagraha — Creating a third option beyond the given menu
  • Partition of India (1947) — Historical choice among tragic options
Quotes
  • “Man is condemned to be free.” — Jean-Paul Sartre
  • “Two roads diverged in a wood, and I— / I took the one less traveled by” — Robert Frost, The Road Not Taken
Pitfalls
  • Writing a "make the right decision" essay — the topic says there may be no right option
  • Ending in relativism or despair; the examiner wants a way forward
  • Ignoring structural constraints that shape the options people face

More from Essay 2022

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.