Critically examine the procedures through which the Presidents of India and France are elected.
Describe both procedures accurately, then weigh their merits and weaknesses against the constitutional design each serves, ending with a judgement.
Common trap: Candidates describe the two procedures but do not examine them. The mode of election must be linked to the role: a nominal head in a parliamentary system in India versus a powerful head in France's semi-presidential Fifth Republic.
SyllabusComparison of the Indian constitutional scheme with that of other countries.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitIndia and France both have a President and a Prime Minister, but the Indian President is a constitutional head bound by ministerial advice, while the French President of the Fifth Republic (1958) holds real executive power. Their modes of election mirror this difference.
- Elected MPs and MLAs vote
- Single transferable vote, secret ballot
- Vote value tied to 1971 population
- Disputes go to the Supreme Court
- Citizens vote directly since 1965
- Two rounds; absolute majority needed
- 500 sponsorships from elected officials
- Constitutional Council proclaims results
The two procedures
| Feature | India | France |
|---|---|---|
| Electorate | Electoral college of elected members of both Houses of Parliament and of State Assemblies, including Delhi and Puducherry (Article 54, 70th Amendment, 1992) | All registered voters, under the 1962 referendum that replaced the electoral college of notables used in 1958 |
| Method | Proportional representation by single transferable vote, secret ballot (Article 55(3)) | Two-round system; if no one wins an absolute majority, the top two meet in a run-off two weeks later |
| Entry filter | 50 proposers and 50 seconders from the electoral college | 500 signatures from mayors and other elected officials across at least 30 departments or overseas territories |
| Term | Five years, re-election allowed (Article 57) | Five years since the 2000 referendum, limited to two consecutive terms since 2008 |
| 2022 outcome | Droupadi Murmu won about 64% of the electoral college vote in July 2022 | Emmanuel Macron was re-elected in April 2022 with about 58.5% in the run-off |
Strengths
- Fit with role in India: Indirect election avoids a rival popular mandate to the Prime Minister, as the Constituent Assembly intended for a nominal head.
- Federal parity: Article 55 balances the States and the Union, so the President represents the whole federation.
- Fit with role in France: A direct mandate legitimises powers such as dissolving the National Assembly (Article 12) and emergency powers (Article 16), and the run-off guarantees majority support.
Limitations
- India: The result is usually predictable from the ruling coalition's strength, cross-voting cannot be checked by whips, and the 84th Amendment (2001) extended the freeze of vote values on the 1971 Census until after 2026.
- France: The sponsorship rule is criticised for screening out candidates, and a President and Assembly of opposite camps produced cohabitation in 1986–88, 1993–95 and 1997–2002, which the shorter, synchronised term sought to prevent.
Each method suits its constitutional design: India's indirect, federal election keeps the head of State above party politics, while France's direct vote anchors a strong executive. Transplanting either would upset the balance each Constitution was built to achieve.
Read more — sources
- OfficialConstitution of India — Articles 54, 55, 57, 71; Presidential and Vice-Presidential Elections Act, 1952
- OfficialConstitution of the French Republic, 1958 — Articles 6, 7, 12, 16, 58 (Conseil constitutionnel, English text)
- NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 4, Executive
- BookSubhash C. Kashyap, Our Constitution
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2022
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.