Nearly all men can stand adversity, but to test the character, give him power.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Declare your reading early and sustain it.
Common trap: The line is popularly attributed to Lincoln, but the attribution is doubtful — do not rest the essay on it. The strong essay explains why power, more than adversity, reveals character: adversity forces endurance, but power removes the external constraints and leaves only the inner ones. It then moves from individuals to institutions — since character cannot be guaranteed, constitutions and accountability must be designed for those whom power tempts — and links naturally to the ethics of civil servants.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Moral-psychological: hardship compels most people to endure; power gives them the freedom to choose, so it reveals what they really value.
- Historical: rulers and leaders are judged less by how they rose than by what they did once they held power — Ashoka after Kalinga, Washington stepping down.
- Institutional: because power tests and often corrupts character, democracies build checks — constitutions, courts, term limits, a free press — rather than trusting virtue alone.
- Everyday-administrative: the clerk, the officer and the policeman hold power over citizens daily; character is revealed in how they use discretion with the weak.
- Critical: adversity also tests character in ways power does not, and power can ennoble as well as corrupt; the line is a provocation, not a law.
Why power is the harder test
- Adversity imposes constraints; power removes them and exposes inner restraint or its absence
- Power brings flattery and isolation that distort judgement
- Plato's Ring of Gyges: what would a person do if they could act without consequence?
Lessons from history
- Ashoka turned from conquest to dhamma after Kalinga
- George Washington gave up power after two terms; Mandela served a single term
- Leaders who clung to power — and the institutions that suffered — offer the contrast
Indian public life
- Lal Bahadur Shastri resigned as Railway Minister after a train accident (1956), owning responsibility
- The Emergency (1975–77) as a test of how power treats constitutional limits
- Gandhi refused office after Independence — moral authority without formal power
Civil service and discretion
- Officers hold power over the vulnerable — the test is fairness to those who cannot complain
- Integrity, impartiality and compassion as foundational values for civil services
- Nolan Principles (UK, 1995): selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty, leadership
Institutions as the safeguard
- Separation of powers, judicial review and free press check those who fail the test
- RTI, Lokpal and audit institutions make power answerable
- Term limits and rotation prevent the slow corrosion of long tenure
The counter-view
- Adversity — poverty, persecution, prison — tests character profoundly; many break under it
- Power can bring out greatness: responsibility has made ordinary people extraordinary
- Character is not fixed; it is shaped by circumstances, culture and institutions
Opening. Open with a contrast: two people who endured the same hardship with courage, one of whom later used power wisely and the other who abused it. Ask which experience truly showed who they were.
Body. Explain why power removes constraints, draw on history (Ashoka, Washington, Mandela), Indian public life (Shastri, the Emergency, Gandhi), the civil servant's daily discretion, and the institutions that guard against failure.
Counter-view. Grant that adversity is a severe test and that power can ennoble; argue that both reveal character, but power reveals it in a way that affects others, which is why it matters more for public life.
Conclusion. Conclude that a wise society both cultivates character and does not depend on it alone. End with the aspirant: the real examination begins not in the exam hall but on the first day in office.
- Ashoka after the Kalinga war — Power used for moral transformation — the test passed
- George Washington stepping down after two terms — Voluntary surrender of power as a mark of character
- Nelson Mandela serving a single presidential term after 27 years in prison — One person tested by both adversity and power
- Lal Bahadur Shastri's resignation as Railway Minister (1956) — Owning moral responsibility while holding office
- The Emergency of 1975–77 and the 44th Amendment safeguards — Power testing institutions, and institutions responding
- Nolan Committee's seven principles of public life (1995) — A framework for judging those who hold public power
- “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” — Lord Acton, letter to Bishop Creighton (1887)
- “If men were angels, no government would be necessary.” — James Madison, Federalist No. 51
- Attributing the topic line confidently to Lincoln
- Writing only about politicians and ignoring power in families, workplaces and offices
- Treating power as inherently evil — the essay should also show power used well
- Stopping at individuals without discussing institutional checks
More from Essay 2024
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.