Achieving sustainable growth with emphasis on environmental protection could come into conflict with poor people’s needs in a country like India. Comment.
Give a reasoned opinion on the statement, taking a position after weighing both where it holds and where it does not.
Common trap: A one-sided answer, either 'conservation hurts the poor' or 'the poor need a clean environment', scores average. The top answer shows the conflict is real at the point of policy design and then shows how design can dissolve it.
SyllabusRole of women and women's organization, population and associated issues, poverty and developmental issues, urbanization, their problems and their remedies.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitAt Stockholm in 1972 Indira Gandhi asked whether poverty and need were not the greatest polluters. The tension she named is real in India, but it arises at the point of policy design, when rules are framed without the poor in mind, not as an iron law of development.
- Forest relocation and access limits
- Coal phase-down in mining districts
- GRAP bans idle daily-wage workers
- Plastic ban hits small vendors
- Unaffordable LPG refills
- Poor bear the worst pollution and heat
- Livelihoods rest on soil, forests, fish
- Degradation driven by industry and affluence
- FRA, MGNREGA works, PM-KUSUM
Where the conflict is real
- Forests and protected areas: Relocation from protected areas and restricted forest access cut into forest dwellers' livelihoods.
- Energy transition: Phasing down coal threatens districts in Jharkhand, Odisha and Chhattisgarh where mining is the main employer.
- Urban rules: Delhi's construction bans under GRAP idle daily-wage workers, and the single-use plastic ban of 2022 hurt small vendors first.
- Clean cooking and seasonal bans: Ujjwala (PMUY) households revert to firewood when refills are unaffordable, and bans on sand mining or monsoon fishing remove seasonal earnings.
Why the statement is incomplete
- Unequal burden: The poor bear the heaviest environmental costs: they breathe the dirtiest air, work through heatwaves, live on flood-prone land and lose most from falling groundwater.
- Natural capital: Their livelihoods rest directly on soil, forests and fisheries, so degradation is itself impoverishing.
- Real drivers: Most degradation stems from industry and affluent consumption, not subsistence.
Reconciling the two by design
| Policy area | Cost to the poor | Design fix |
|---|---|---|
| Forests | Loss of access and livelihood | Forest Rights Act, 2006 and Joint Forest Management make communities custodians |
| Coal | Loss of mining jobs | A just transition for coal regions |
| Clean cooking | Return to firewood when refills are costly | Affordable refills for Ujjwala households |
| Seasonal bans | Lost earnings | Compensation during the ban |
| Rural livelihoods | Dependence on degraded land | MGNREGA water and land works; PM-KUSUM solar pumps |
- Global parallel: India's stand on common but differentiated responsibilities applies the same logic between nations.
Sustainable growth conflicts with the poor only when its costs are passed down to those least able to bear them. The Brundtland definition of 1987 put the needs of the poor at its core, and Indian policy succeeds when it does the same.
Read more — sources
- ReportWorld Commission on Environment and Development, Our Common Future (Brundtland Report, 1987) — Ch. 2, Towards Sustainable Development
- NCERTIndian Economic Development (Class XI) — Ch. 7, Environment and Sustainable Development
- OfficialThe Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 1 2025
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.