Does genetic engineering offer significant advancements in the field of agriculture? How can this technology help to uplift the socio-economic status of farmers?
Take a reasoned position on whether genetic engineering has delivered significant advances, weighing evidence and limits, and then explain concretely how it can raise farmers' incomes and well-being.
Common trap: Answers that only praise or only oppose GM crops lose marks. Use Indian evidence (Bt cotton, GM mustard, genome-edited rice), distinguish transgenic crops from genome editing, and address biosafety, seed costs and regulation.
SyllabusAwareness in the fields of IT, Space, Computers, robotics, nano-technology, bio-technology and issues relating to intellectual property rights.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitGenetic engineering alters a crop's DNA directly, either by inserting a foreign gene (transgenics) or by editing its own genes. India's only commercial GM crop, Bt cotton approved in 2002, now covers over 90 percent of cotton area, while India released its first genome-edited rice varieties in May 2025.
- Foreign gene inserted
- Bt cotton, GM mustard DMH-11
- Regulated by GEAC under 1989 Rules
- Biosafety and public concerns
- Crop's own genes edited
- DRR Dhan 100 (Kamala), Pusa DST Rice 1
- SDN-1 and SDN-2 exempted in 2022
- Faster, cheaper, no foreign DNA
Significant advancements
- Pest resistance: Bt cotton helped India's cotton output roughly treble to a record of nearly 400 lakh bales by 2013-14 and cut early-season pesticide use against bollworm.
- Hybrid vigour and yield: GM mustard DMH-11, developed at Delhi University and approved for environmental release by GEAC in 2022, uses a barnase-barstar system to make hybrid seed production easier.
- Climate resilience: Genome-edited rice varieties released by ICAR in 2025 aim at higher yield, drought and salinity tolerance and shorter duration that saves water.
- Nutrition: Traits such as beta-carotene in Golden Rice, cleared in the Philippines in 2021 though a court halted it in 2024, show how micronutrient deficiencies can be targeted.
Limits and concerns
- Resistance and costs: Pink bollworm resistance to Bt cotton and illegal herbicide-tolerant seed show that traits erode without stewardship.
- Regulatory uncertainty: The Bt brinjal moratorium (2010) and the Supreme Court's split verdict on GM mustard (July 2024), which directed the Centre to frame a national GM policy, have slowed adoption.
Uplifting farmers' socio-economic status
- Higher, stable incomes: Higher yields and lower losses from pests, drought and salinity reduce income shocks for rainfed smallholders.
- Lower input costs: Fewer pesticide sprays and less water and fertiliser cut cultivation costs and health risks from spraying.
- Import substitution: Higher-yielding oilseeds can cut India's large edible oil import bill and raise farm-gate prices.
- Equitable access: Public-sector traits from ICAR, affordable seed pricing and FPO-based seed distribution can stop gains being captured by seed companies.
Genetic engineering offers real advances, but it is a tool, not a silver bullet. A science-based, transparent regulatory policy, public-sector research under the BioE3 vision and strong biosafety monitoring can let farmers capture its gains while protecting biodiversity and consumer trust.
Read more — sources
- OfficialICAR / Ministry of Agriculture, PIB release on genome-edited rice varieties (May 2025)
- OfficialSupreme Court of India, Gene Campaign v. Union of India, judgment of 23 July 2024
- OfficialMoEFCC, Rules for the Manufacture, Use, Import, Export and Storage of Hazardous Micro-organisms, Genetically Engineered Organisms or Cells, 1989
- OfficialMinistry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare, Cotton Advisory Board / Committee on Cotton Production and Consumption estimates
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 3 2025
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.