“Tundra regions are ecologically fragile but economically important.” Examine this statement critically.
Test the claim against evidence and deliver a judgement — a two-sided list without a verdict is incomplete.
Common trap: 'Critically' demands a verdict, not a two-sided list. The mark lies in showing the two halves are causally connected rather than merely coexisting.
SyllabusSalient features of the world's physical geography; distribution of key natural resources across the world.
Model answer
158 words · 150-word limitThe tundra combines the slowest ecological recovery rates on earth with some of its largest untapped hydrocarbon endowments, so the statement describes a dilemma rather than a contradiction.
Fragility is structural: a growing season of weeks and simple food chains such as lichen–caribou–wolf mean disturbance cascades and recovery takes decades. Permafrost thaw releases methane and carbon dioxide, and Arctic amplification warms the region two to three times faster than the global average.
Economic importance is equally real — a significant share of undiscovered oil and gas, Norilsk nickel, Greenland rare earths, and the Northern Sea Route opening as sea ice retreats.
The two are causally linked: extraction infrastructure accelerates the permafrost thaw that destabilises it, cold-water spills persist far longer, and Inuit, Sami and Nenets livelihoods are displaced by the activity generating revenue.
Governance remains contested through the Arctic Council and UNCLOS claims, where India participates as Observer. Both halves are true — and that is the problem.
Answer plan — how to structure itShowHide
Open with: The tundra — treeless biome above roughly 60°N and on high mountains — combines the planet's slowest ecological recovery rates with some of its largest untapped hydrocarbon and mineral reserves.
The case for fragility
- Extremely short growing season and low productivity — lichens and mosses take decades to recolonise disturbed ground
- Simple food chains (lichen–caribou–wolf) mean the loss of one link cascades
- Permafrost thaw releases stored methane and CO2, a positive feedback amplifying global warming
- Arctic amplification — the region warms at roughly two to three times the global average
The case for economic importance
- Substantial share of the world's undiscovered oil and natural gas lies in the Arctic
- Strategic minerals — nickel at Norilsk, rare earths and phosphates in Greenland, diamonds in the Canadian Arctic
- Retreating sea ice is opening the Northern Sea Route, cutting Asia–Europe transit distance substantially
- Fisheries, reindeer herding and, increasingly, Arctic tourism
The critical tension
- Extraction infrastructure itself accelerates permafrost thaw, so the economy undermines its own foundation
- Oil spills in cold water degrade far more slowly than in the tropics
- Indigenous livelihoods — Inuit, Sami, Nenets — are displaced by the same activity that generates national revenue
- Governance is contested: Arctic Council, UNCLOS continental-shelf claims; India holds Observer status and runs Himadri station
Draw: A balance diagram — fragility indicators on one arm, resource endowments on the other, with permafrost thaw drawn as the common fulcrum.
Close with: Both halves of the statement are true, and that is the problem: economic importance is realised through exactly the activities that trigger ecological collapse.
Read more — sources
- NCERTFundamentals of Physical Geography (Class XI) — Ch. 16, Biosphere; World Geography Ch. on biomes
- BookGoh Cheng Leong — Cold Climates; MoES releases on India's Arctic Policy
- EdiShorts appGeography — World Biomes & Polar Regions
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 1 2026
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.