EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2019 GS Paper 1 Q45 · Polity & Governance

Year2019
PaperGS Paper 1
QuestionQ45
SubjectPolity & Governance

Consider the following statements :
1. The 44th Amendment to the Constitution of India introduced an Article placing the election of the Prime Minister beyond judicial review.
2. The Supreme Court of India struck down the 99th Amendment to the Constitution of India as being violative of the independence of judiciary.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. a1 only
  2. b2 only
  3. cBoth 1 and 2
  4. dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) 2 only

The 39th Amendment, not the 44th, shielded the PM's election; the Supreme Court did strike down the 99th Amendment (NJAC) in 2015.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Statement 1
  • Article 329A, which put disputes over the election of the PM and the Speaker beyond the courts, was inserted by the 39th Amendment (1975) during the Emergency.
  • The 44th Amendment (1978) repealed Article 329A and undid many Emergency-era changes.
✓ Statement 2
  • In Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India (2015, Fourth Judges case) a 4:1 Constitution Bench struck down the 99th Amendment and the NJAC Act.
  • It held that judicial primacy in appointments is part of the independence of the judiciary, a basic feature, and revived the collegium system.

Concept to know

  • Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975): the Supreme Court struck down clause (4) of Article 329A for violating free and fair elections and judicial review, both part of the basic structure.
  • The basic structure doctrine comes from Kesavananda Bharati (1973): Parliament can amend any part of the Constitution but not destroy its basic features.
  • The 42nd Amendment (1976) tried to make amendments immune from review (Article 368(4) and (5)); Minerva Mills (1980) struck those clauses down.
  • The 44th Amendment also removed the right to property from Fundamental Rights (it became Article 300A), replaced 'internal disturbance' with 'armed rebellion' for an emergency, and made Articles 20 and 21 non-suspendable.
  • The NJAC was to have six members: the CJI, the two senior-most SC judges, the Law Minister and two eminent persons; the veto of any two members worried the Court.

Related facts for revision

  • Judges cases: First (S.P. Gupta, 1981), Second (1993, created the collegium), Third (1998 Presidential reference, widened the collegium to the CJI plus four judges).
  • Articles 124 and 217 deal with appointing judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts.
  • The 39th Amendment also placed certain election laws in the Ninth Schedule.
  • Other amendments struck down for violating the basic structure: parts of the 42nd (Minerva Mills) and the Tenth Schedule's para 7 bar on judicial review (Kihoto Hollohan, 1992).
How UPSC tests this

Which Emergency-era amendment did what, and the outcome of a landmark case on judicial independence.

Trap: The 39th, 42nd and 44th Amendments all relate to the Emergency; the 44th is the one that reversed Emergency excesses, not created them.

Read more: M. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity (chapters on Basic Structure and the Supreme Court)

More Polity & Governance PYQs

All Polity & Governance questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.