EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2026 GS Paper 1 Q12 · Modern History

Year2026
PaperGS Paper 1
QuestionQ12
SubjectModern History

The artificially fixed rupee-sterling exchange rate prescribed by the Hilton-Young Commission (1926) was adopted by the British Government for which one of the following reasons?

  1. aAiding flow of remittances from India and maintaining India's creditworthiness
  2. bProviding support to Indian importers
  3. cEncouraging export of cotton produce
  4. dPreventing depreciation of the Rupee in terms of gold
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(a) Aiding flow of remittances from India and maintaining India's creditworthiness

Fixing the rupee at an overvalued 1s 6d sterling meant fewer rupees were needed to pay India's sterling obligations (Home Charges), which eased remittances to England and protected India's standing with British creditors.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✓ Option (a)
  • The Hilton-Young Commission fixed Rupee = 1s 6d sterling, above the pre-war 1s 4d. This made the rupee overvalued.
  • An overvalued rupee cut the rupee cost of Home Charges, such as interest on sterling debt, pensions and India Office expenses, which were remitted to England.
  • Cheaper servicing of sterling obligations protected British creditors and kept India's credit good in the London money market.
✗ Option (b)
  • An overvalued rupee did make imports cheaper, but the policy was not framed to help Indian importers.
  • The real beneficiaries of cheaper imports were British manufacturers exporting to India. Their goods competed with Indian industry.
✗ Option (c)
  • Overvaluation makes Indian goods dearer abroad, so it discourages exports rather than encouraging them.
  • Indian exporters, including those dealing in cotton and agricultural produce, suffered from the 1s 6d ratio. This is why Indian business opposed it.
✗ Option (d)
  • The controversial ratio was fixed in terms of sterling, and its purpose was to ease remittances and protect creditors.
  • It was not aimed at preventing the rupee's depreciation against gold.
  • The Commission did recommend a gold bullion standard as the currency arrangement, but that was a separate recommendation from the reason for the 1s 6d rate.

Concept to know

  • The Royal Commission on Indian Currency and Finance was chaired by Edward Hilton Young and submitted its report in 1926. It recommended a rupee-sterling ratio of 1s 6d.
  • The Currency Act of 1927 gave legal effect to the 1s 6d ratio.
  • Home Charges were expenditure incurred in England on India's account, including interest on public debt, civil and military pensions, salaries and India Office costs. They are central to the Drain of Wealth argument.
  • An overvalued currency lowers the domestic cost of foreign payments and imports but makes exports less competitive. Hence Indian exporters and industry were hurt.
  • The Commission also recommended a central bank for India, which was later realised through the RBI Act, 1934. The RBI began functioning in 1935.
  • The ratio controversy pitted Indian businessmen and nationalists, who wanted 1s 4d, against the Government. Sir Purshottamdas Thakurdas wrote a minute of dissent within the Commission.

Related facts for revision

  • The Babington Smith Committee (1919) had earlier recommended a high rupee value of 2 shillings (gold). The attempt to maintain it failed and caused heavy losses.
  • In 1931, Britain left the gold standard and the rupee was linked to sterling at 1s 6d. Large exports of distress gold from India followed during the Depression.
  • Dadabhai Naoroji's Poverty and Un-British Rule in India popularised the Drain of Wealth theory, with Home Charges as a major component.
  • The exchange ratio controversy helped bring Indian capitalists together. FICCI was founded in 1927, with G.D. Birla and Purshottamdas Thakurdas among its prominent figures.
  • The Hilton-Young Commission (currency, 1926) is different from the Hilton Young Commission on closer union of East African territories (1927–29). Do not confuse the two.
How UPSC tests this

UPSC was testing whether aspirants understand colonial monetary policy as a tool serving British financial interests, and how currency overvaluation links to Home Charges and the Drain of Wealth.

Trap: Aspirants often apply a modern logic, such as a stable rupee to prevent depreciation or support for trade. An overvalued rupee hurts exports, and its cheaper imports mainly benefited British manufacturers. The core colonial motive was easier sterling remittances and creditor protection.

More Modern History PYQs

All Modern History questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.