EdiShorts

Civil Liberties Watch: The Case for UAPA Reform and the NHRC at 33

IssueOctober 2026
PaperGS Paper 2
SubjectPolity & Governance
Read time4 min

Why in News: On 12 October 2026 two anniversaries renewed the civil-liberties debate: the death of former Delhi University professor G.N. Saibaba (12 October 2024), months after the Bombay High Court acquitted him of UAPA charges following about ten years in prison; and the 33rd Foundation Day of the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), set up on 12 October 1993. The October protests over the SIR and the UN human-rights statements on detentions added urgency to questions about anti-terror law and human-rights institutions.

The UAPA Debate

  • Bail bar: Section 43D(5) of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 denies bail if the accusation appears “prima facie true”; NIA v. Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali (2019) told courts not to weigh evidence at the bail stage, making bail rare.
  • Long incarceration: Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb (2021) held that prolonged pre-trial detention can justify bail under Article 21 despite the statutory bar; Vernon Gonsalves (2023) required courts to test the quality of evidence; Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh (2024) said “bail is the rule” applies even to UAPA.
  • Low conviction rates: NCRB data have shown conviction in only a small share of UAPA cases decided, while cases take years to reach trial.
  • The 2019 amendment allows the Centre to designate individuals (not only organisations) as terrorists and lets NIA officers of Inspector rank investigate.

Reform Ideas

  • Time-bound trials through special courts; bail after a fixed period of custody if trial has not begun.
  • Independent review of sanction for prosecution; compensation for wrongful incarceration (Law Commission Report No. 277, 2018).
  • Narrower definitions of “unlawful activity” and of support to terrorist organisations.

The NHRC at 33

  • Strengths: suo motu cognisance, inquiries into custodial deaths, guidelines on encounters, bonded labour and mental health.
  • Weaknesses: recommendations are not binding; no power over armed forces (it can only seek a report); one-year limitation for complaints; heavy dependence on officers deputed from government.
  • International standing: the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions (GANHRI) deferred the NHRC’s “A” status re-accreditation in 2023 and 2024, citing appointment processes and pluralism.

Static Background — UAPA and Human-Rights Institutions

  • UAPA, 1967: enacted after the 16th Amendment (1963) allowed reasonable restrictions in the interest of sovereignty and integrity; strengthened after POTA was repealed (2004). Custody: up to 30 days police custody; charge-sheet within 180 days.
  • Protection of Human Rights Act (PHRA), 1993 — NHRC composition: Chairperson (a former Chief Justice of India or a former Supreme Court judge — after the 2019 amendment), one former SC judge, one former HC Chief Justice, three members with human-rights knowledge (one a woman), plus ex officio chairs of national commissions (SC, ST, Women, Minorities, Backward Classes, Children, Persons with Disabilities).
  • Appointment: by the President on a committee of the PM (chair), Lok Sabha Speaker, Union Home Minister, Leaders of Opposition in both Houses and the Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha.
  • Term: three years or age 70; eligible for reappointment (2019 amendment).
  • State Human Rights Commissions are appointed by the Governor; Human Rights Courts may be set up in each district.
Body / lawKey fact
NHRCStatutory, PHRA 1993; recommendations not binding
UAPA Sec 43D(5)Bail bar if accusation prima facie true
K.A. Najeeb (2021)Long custody can justify bail despite UAPA
GANHRIAccredits national human rights institutions (Paris Principles, 1993)

Exam Angle — Prelims & Mains

  • UPSC PYQ Link: Mains GS-2 has asked whether the NHRC can be effective without binding powers; Prelims has asked on the Paris Principles and NHRC composition.
  • Practice Mains Question (GS Paper 2, 15 marks, 250 words): Stringent anti-terror laws are necessary, but procedure itself should not become the punishment. Examine the case for reforming the UAPA with reference to recent judgments.
  • Prelims Angle: NHRC composition and appointment committee; UAPA designation of individuals.
    • Practice Prelims MCQ 1: Consider the following statements regarding the National Human Rights Commission:
      1. Its Chairperson must be a person who has been the Chief Justice of India.
      2. The Chairpersons of the National Commission for Women and the National Commission for Minorities are ex officio members.
      3. The Leaders of Opposition in both Houses of Parliament are members of the committee that recommends appointments.
      How many of the statements given above are correct?
      (A) Only one
      (B) Only two
      (C) All three
      (D) None
      Show answer
      Answer: (B) Only two — Statement 1 is INCORRECT — since 2019 a former Supreme Court judge can also be appointed. Statement 2 is CORRECT and Statement 3 is CORRECT under the PHRA, 1993.
    • Practice Prelims MCQ 2: Which amendment to the UAPA empowered the Central Government to designate an individual as a terrorist?
      (A) The 2004 amendment
      (B) The 2008 amendment
      (C) The 2012 amendment
      (D) The 2019 amendment
      Show answer
      Answer: (D) — The 2019 amendment allowed individuals to be listed in the Fourth Schedule as terrorists; earlier only organisations could be designated.

More Polity & Governance from October 2026

Written by the EdiShorts editorial team from official and public sources. Check the latest position before quoting figures in the exam.