Role of the media in good governance.
1800–2000 words, 200 marks. In the old pattern (2008) the candidate wrote ONE essay chosen from six topics. Graded on understanding of the topic, orderly arrangement of ideas and concise expression. A 'role of X in Y' topic: define good governance, then show what the media adds, where it fails, and what makes it a positive force.
Common trap: Weak essays list the functions of the press or praise it as the 'fourth estate'. The top essay first defines good governance (transparency, accountability, participation, rule of law, responsiveness), maps each to a media function, then honestly weighs the 2008 problems — TRP-driven sensationalism, media trials, commercial pressure, sensational crime and hostage coverage — and ends with self-regulation plus media literacy, not state control.
Essay brief
1800–2000 words · 125 marks- Watchdog reading: the media holds power to account by exposing corruption and maladministration — the 'fourth estate'.
- Bridge reading: the media carries information from government to citizen and grievances from citizen to government, making governance participatory.
- Balanced reading: the media is an essential but imperfect partner of good governance; its value depends on its own ethics, ownership and independence (strongest reading).
- Critical reading: a commercialised, sensational media can distort governance — trial by media, panic, and agenda-setting by owners and advertisers.
What good governance needs
- World Bank / UNDP elements: accountability, transparency, participation, rule of law, responsiveness
- Informed citizens are the precondition of accountable government
- Article 19(1)(a): press freedom read into free speech (Romesh Thappar 1950, Sakal Papers 1962)
Media as watchdog
- Investigative journalism: Bofors (The Hindu, 1987–89), Tehelka's defence-deals sting (2001)
- Public campaigns after the Jessica Lal (2006) and Priyadarshini Mattoo verdicts led to retrials and convictions
- Exposing gaps in relief, health and PDS delivery that files never reveal
Media as bridge and educator
- Spreading awareness of schemes and rights — NREGA (2005), RTI Act (2005)
- Community radio policy (2006) gives local voice to villages
- Amartya Sen: no major famine in a democracy with a free press
Media and participation
- Agenda-setting for public debate on reforms, environment, gender
- Election coverage and voter awareness
- Citizen journalism, blogs and SMS campaigns are emerging new voices
Where the media fails
- Sensationalism and TRP race; trivia crowds out rural and development news (P. Sainath's critique)
- Media trials prejudice fair investigation and reputations (Aarushi Talwar case, 2008)
- Round-the-clock spectacle (the 2006 Prince borewell rescue) while rural distress went unreported
- Concentrated ownership, advertiser pressure and political ownership of channels
Making the media a better partner
- Self-regulation: Press Council of India for print; a broadcasters' self-regulatory code under discussion
- Editorial independence from owners; fact-checking and corrections
- Media literacy among citizens; public broadcaster Prasar Bharati with real autonomy
- Government transparency (RTI, proactive disclosure) gives the media facts, not rumours
Opening. Open with Jefferson's line about preferring newspapers without a government, or with a recent case where a news story forced a government to act — then define good governance in five words.
Body. Show the media as watchdog, bridge and forum for participation, each tied to an element of good governance, with Indian examples up to 2008.
Counter-view. Give a full section to the failures — sensationalism, media trials, owner and advertiser influence — showing that a bad media can harm governance.
Conclusion. Close with the idea that a free press and a good government need each other: freedom with responsibility, regulated by the profession and judged by informed readers, not by the state.
- Bofors exposé by The Hindu (1987–89) — Investigative journalism holding the highest offices to account
- Jessica Lal case retrial and conviction (2006) — Public pressure built by media correcting a failure of justice
- Right to Information Act, 2005 — Transparency law that strengthens journalism and citizen oversight
- Amartya Sen's famine thesis — Free press as an early-warning system for government
- (Later: live TV coverage of the 26/11 Mumbai attacks, Nov 2008) — Showed how live coverage can aid attackers; led to broadcast guidelines
- Aarushi Talwar case coverage (2008) — Trial by media and damage to reputations and investigation
- P. Sainath's reporting on rural distress and farmer suicides — What development journalism should look like
- “Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers, or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.” — Thomas Jefferson
- “The sole aim of journalism should be service.” — Mahatma Gandhi
- Writing only a list of media functions without linking each to good governance
- Uncritical praise of the media, or a one-sided attack on it
- Calling for government control of the press as the solution
- Citing later events (paid news 2009, social media, 2010s scams) as if current in 2008
More from Essay 2008
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.