Urbanisation and its hazards.
1800–2000 words, 200 marks. In the old pattern (2008) the candidate wrote ONE essay chosen from six topics. Graded on understanding of the topic, orderly arrangement of ideas and concise expression. The topic names the hazards, but a good essay first shows why urbanisation is inevitable and beneficial, then the hazards, then the remedies.
Common trap: Weak essays list pollution, slums and traffic. The top essay gives the 2008 picture (Census 2001: about 28% urban, 35 million-plus cities; slums; JNNURM 2005), classifies the hazards — environmental, social, health, disaster and governance — explains their cause (unplanned growth, weak urban local bodies despite the 74th Amendment), and proposes planning-based solutions, ending on urbanisation as an opportunity to be managed.
Essay brief
1800–2000 words · 125 marks- Environmental reading: cities concentrate pollution, waste, water stress and urban flooding.
- Social reading: slums, informal work, crime and social isolation are the human hazards of unplanned urban growth.
- Governance reading: the hazards are not of urbanisation itself but of unplanned, poorly governed urbanisation (strongest reading).
- Balanced reading: cities are engines of growth and freedom from caste; the goal is to manage, not stop, urbanisation.
The urban transition
- Census 2001: about 28% urban, 35 cities with a million-plus population
- Push of agrarian distress and pull of jobs; cities produce a large share of GDP
- Ambedkar saw the city as an escape from the village's caste oppression
Environmental hazards
- Air pollution; Delhi's CNG shift (2002) after Supreme Court orders
- Untreated sewage in rivers — Yamuna despite the Yamuna Action Plan
- Solid waste and landfill crises; loss of wetlands and green cover
- Urban heat islands
Social and health hazards
- Slums: Dharavi in Mumbai; insecure tenure and poor sanitation
- Water-borne and vector-borne disease — dengue, chikungunya outbreaks
- Crime, isolation of the elderly, road deaths, informal and insecure jobs
Disaster hazards
- Mumbai floods, 26 July 2005: about 944 mm of rain in a day, blocked Mithi river and drains
- Building collapses and seismic risk in dense cities
- Fires and industrial accidents — Bhopal (1984) as the worst urban industrial disaster
Governance gaps
- 74th Amendment (1992) on urban local bodies poorly implemented; weak municipal finances
- Outdated master plans, land mafia, unauthorised colonies
- Public transport neglected for private vehicles
Managing urbanisation
- JNNURM (2005): reforms-linked funding for 63 mission cities, BSUP for the urban poor
- Metro rail and bus rapid transit; National Urban Transport Policy (2006)
- Rainwater harvesting, sewage treatment, waste segregation
- Develop small towns and rural non-farm jobs to reduce pressure — PURA concept
Opening. Open with Mumbai on 26 July 2005 — a city of dreams paralysed by one day's rain — and ask whether the fault lies in the rain or in the way the city grew.
Body. Describe the urban transition, then classify hazards: environmental, social and health, disaster, and governance, each with Indian examples.
Counter-view. Give a paragraph to the other side: cities give jobs, mobility and freedom; the answer is not to stop migration but to plan for it.
Conclusion. Close with a vision of planned, inclusive cities governed by empowered local bodies — cities that are engines, not hazards.
- Mumbai floods, 26 July 2005 — Unplanned growth turning rain into disaster
- Dharavi, Mumbai — Scale of slum life and informal economy
- Delhi's CNG transition (2002) — Court-driven fix of urban air pollution
- 74th Constitutional Amendment (1992) — Framework for urban self-government, weakly implemented
- JNNURM (2005) — National mission for urban infrastructure and the urban poor
- Delhi Metro (from 2002) — Mass transit as a remedy for congestion
- Surat after the 1994 plague — Turnaround to one of India's cleanest cities through municipal action
- “The village is a sink of localism, a den of ignorance, narrow-mindedness and communalism.” — B. R. Ambedkar (Constituent Assembly, 1948)
- “India lives in her villages.” — Mahatma Gandhi
- Listing hazards without causes and remedies
- Treating urbanisation as bad in itself
- No Indian data or examples
- Citing later schemes (Smart Cities 2015, AMRUT, Census 2011) as current in 2008
More from Essay 2008
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.