What is meant by ‘Judicial Activism’ ? Evaluate its role in the context of the functioning of Indian polity.
Define judicial activism, then weigh its positive contributions against its costs (overreach, separation of powers, implementation) and give a reasoned verdict.
Common trap: Weak answers either praise or condemn activism. A top answer defines it precisely, uses landmark cases (Kesavananda, Maneka, Vishaka, Hussainara, Vineet Narain), notes the 2007–08 debate on overreach, and ends with a balanced verdict.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper I (2006–12): Indian Polity — Constitution, political system, institutions
Model answer
30 marks · 250-word limitJudicial activism means the judiciary going beyond a narrow, literal reading of law to protect rights and correct failures of the executive and legislature. In India it grew after the Emergency through public interest litigation (PIL) and an expansive reading of Article 21, using Articles 32, 136, 142 and 226.
- Basic structure doctrine
- Wider Article 21 rights
- PIL for the voiceless
- Accountability (Vineet Narain)
- Environment orders
- Overreach into policy
- Separation of powers blurred
- Weak implementation
- Rising pendency
Tools and landmarks
- Basic structure: Kesavananda Bharati (1973) limited Parliament's power to amend the Constitution.
- Expanding Article 21: Maneka Gandhi (1978) held that 'procedure established by law' must be just, fair and reasonable; later cases read in rights to livelihood, shelter, health, education and a clean environment.
- PIL: S. P. Gupta (1981) relaxed locus standi; Hussainara Khatoon (1979) freed undertrial prisoners; Bandhua Mukti Morcha (1984) dealt with bonded labour.
Positive role
- Filling gaps: Vishaka (1997) laid down guidelines on sexual harassment at the workplace in the absence of a law.
- Accountability: Vineet Narain (1997), the hawala case, used continuing mandamus to monitor the probe and gave the CBI and CVC greater independence.
- Environment and governance: M. C. Mehta cases led to CNG buses in Delhi; the PUCL right-to-food case (2001) expanded mid-day meals; election candidates had to disclose assets and criminal records (2002).
Concerns
- Overreach: Courts making policy or running administration blurs separation of powers; in 2007 the Supreme Court itself warned against judicial overreach in the Aravali Golf Club case.
- Accountability and capacity: Judges are not elected, lack expertise and cannot easily monitor implementation.
- Workload: Frivolous PILs add to a huge pendency of cases.
Evaluation
- Why it arose: Activism grew because of executive inaction, legislative paralysis and the collapse of governance in many areas, so it is a symptom as much as a cause.
- Balance needed: Clear guidelines to filter PILs (later laid down in State of Uttaranchal v Balwant Singh Chaufal, 2010) and judicial self-restraint can preserve activism's gains while respecting legislative and executive domains.
Judicial activism has made Indian democracy more responsive, especially for the voiceless. Its legitimacy rests on restraint: courts should act where rights are violated and other organs fail, but should not replace them. Strengthening executive and legislative performance is the real remedy.
Read more — sources
- BookM. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity
- BookD. D. Basu, Introduction to the Constitution of India
- BookGranville Austin, Working a Democratic Constitution
More from GS Paper I (old) 2008
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.