EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2008GS Paper I (old)Q8(b) · 30 marksPolityModel answer

Do you think there is a need for a review of the Indian Constitution ? Justify your view.

DirectiveJustify
Marks30
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper I (old)
What the examiner wants

Take a clear position (review of the working of the Constitution, not replacement) and justify it with the record of the Constitution, the NCRWC experience and the basic-structure limits.

Common trap: Weak answers sit on the fence or call for a new Constitution. A top answer takes a position, distinguishes review of working from rewriting, cites the NCRWC (2000–02) and Kesavananda Bharati, and gives specific areas needing reform.

SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper I (2006–12): Indian Polity — Constitution, political system, institutions

Model answer

30 marks · 250-word limit

The Constitution has endured since 1950 and has been amended over ninety times by 2008. The question of review was raised officially when the NDA government set up the National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (NCRWC) under Justice M. N. Venkatachaliah in 2000, which reported in 2002.

Case for review
  • Criminalisation and defections
  • Misuse of Article 356
  • Federal and fiscal strains
  • New challenges since 1950
vs
Limits on review
  • Basic structure doctrine
  • Flexible Article 368
  • Fear of hidden agendas
  • Problems lie in working
Reviewing the Indian Constitution

Why a review is needed

  • Governance deficits: Criminalisation of politics, defections, unstable coalitions and misuse of Article 356 show gaps in political institutions.
  • Federal strains: Centre-state relations, Governors' role and fiscal imbalance need fresh thinking, as the Punchhi Commission (2007) shows.
  • Rights and justice: Delays in courts, police accountability and new rights such as education (86th Amendment, 2002) require updates.
  • Emerging issues: Environment, internal security, globalisation and coalition politics were not foreseen in 1950.

Why not a new Constitution

  • Basic structure: Kesavananda Bharati (1973) bars destroying the basic structure, so wholesale replacement is neither legal nor needed.
  • Proven flexibility: Article 368 has allowed adaptation, such as the 73rd and 74th Amendments and the Anti-Defection Law (52nd and 91st Amendments).
  • Fears: Opposition parties in 2000 feared that review was a cover to change the parliamentary system or secular character.

What the NCRWC suggested

  • Examples: It gave 249 recommendations, including curbs on Article 356, stronger anti-defection rules, a National Judicial Commission and electoral reforms, mostly within the existing framework; several, such as limiting the size of ministries (91st Amendment, 2003), were adopted.

My view

  • Review, not rewrite: A periodic review of the working of the Constitution is useful, but changes must respect its basic features and come through broad consensus.
  • Method: Review should be done by an expert, non-partisan body, followed by debate in Parliament and the states, so that amendments carry legitimacy and are not seen as one party's agenda.

The Constitution's problems lie largely in its working, not its framework. As Dr. Ambedkar warned, a good Constitution can fail if those who work it are bad; India needs better implementation and consensual, targeted amendments rather than a new document.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 313 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • BookM. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity
  • ReportNational Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (Venkatachaliah Commission), Report (2002)
  • BookGranville Austin, Working a Democratic Constitution

More from GS Paper I (old) 2008

Q1(a)·15 marks·150 words·History
“The emergence of new social classes in British India was the direct consequence of the establishment of new social economy, new state system, administrative machinery and Western education.” Discuss.
Colonial rule replaced a largely self-sufficient, status-bound society with a market economy, a centralised bureaucratic state and an English-educated elite. A. R.…
Read the model answer →
Q1(b)·15 marks·150 words·History
“British vision of India had no single coherent set of ideas. On the contrary, the ideas were shot through with contradictions and inconsistencies.” Discuss.
Thomas Metcalf in 'Ideologies of the Raj' argues that the British never had one theory of India. Their thinking moved between respect for Indian tradition and contempt…
Read the model answer →
Q1(c)·15 marks·150 words·History
“Non-Cooperation Movement gave new direction and energy to the National Movement.” Explain.
Launched on 1 August 1920 and endorsed at the Calcutta special session and the Nagpur session of the Congress (1920), the Non-Cooperation Movement was the first…
Read the model answer →
Q2(a)·2 marks·20 words·History
Write a short note on: Lakshmi Bai, Rani of Jhansi
Rani Lakshmi Bai of Jhansi was a leading figure of the Revolt of 1857.
Read the model answer →
Q2(b)·2 marks·20 words·History
Write a short note on: Ilbert Bill
The Ilbert Bill (1883), under Viceroy Ripon, sought to let Indian judges try Europeans in criminal cases.
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.