Critically analyse the following statement with reference to the context in which it was made: “Many Englishmen honestly consider themselves the trustees for India and yet to what a condition they have reduced our country.”
Place the statement in its context (the nationalist critique of British trusteeship), explain what it argues, then weigh how far it is justified and where it overstates.
Common trap: Weak answers only describe British exploitation. A strong answer explains the trusteeship claim (Burke, Macaulay, the civilising mission), sets it against the drain and impoverishment critique, notes that the speaker blames the system rather than individual Englishmen, and ends with a balanced verdict.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper I (2006–12): Indian History & Culture — modern Indian history and the freedom struggle
Model answer
15 marks · 150-word limitThe statement is in the idiom of Gandhi (it is commonly attributed to him) and sums up the moral core of the nationalist case against British rule: individual Englishmen could be sincere, yet the system they ran impoverished India. It contrasts the British claim of trusteeship with its results.
- Burke: power held as a trust
- Macaulay: civilising mission
- Rule of law and railways
- Peace and administrative unity
- Drain of wealth (Naoroji)
- Deindustrialisation of crafts
- Recurring famines
- Political helplessness
Context: the idea of trusteeship
- Origins: Edmund Burke, in his 1783 speech on Fox's East India Bill, argued that power over India was a trust to be exercised for the benefit of Indians.
- Civilising mission: Macaulay's Minute of 1835 and later liberal imperialists presented British rule as tutelage that would one day prepare India for self-government.
- Gandhi's framing: Gandhi repeatedly separated Englishmen from the system: he condemned British rule as a curse while refusing to hate the British people, a stand restated in his letter to Lord Irwin before the Dandi March (1930).
Why the statement holds
- Economic drain: Dadabhai Naoroji's Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901) and R.C. Dutt's Economic History of India showed wealth flowing to Britain through Home Charges and salaries.
- Ruin of crafts: Free entry of Lancashire cloth destroyed handloom weaving, pushing artisans onto an already crowded land.
- Famine and poverty: The famines of 1876–78 and 1896–1900 killed millions while grain was still exported and relief was stingy.
- Moral degradation: Gandhi's deeper charge was that India had been made helpless, unarmed and dependent, which no honest intention could justify.
Where it needs qualification
- Positive by-products: Railways, the telegraph, a uniform legal system, the press and English education also created the very tools of Indian nationalism.
- Internal causes: Social divisions and the political fragmentation of the eighteenth century had eased British conquest; not every ill was imposed from outside.
The statement is substantially valid: good intentions did not change an extractive structure, and nationalists rightly judged empire by its results. Its strength lies in attacking the system rather than individuals, which allowed Gandhi to fight British rule without hatred and kept the door open to a negotiated, non-violent transfer of power.
Read more — sources
- NCERTBipan Chandra, Modern India (old NCERT, Class XII) — Ch. on economic impact of British rule
- BookBipan Chandra et al., India's Struggle for Independence — Ch. on the economic critique of colonialism
- BookDadabhai Naoroji, Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901)
More from GS Paper I (old) 2009
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.