EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2009GS Paper I (old)Q5(c) · 10 marksArt & CultureModel answer

What are the important similarities and differences between the Hindustani and the Carnatic styles of classical music?

DirectiveWhat are
Marks10
Word limit100
PaperGS Paper I (old)
What the examiner wants

Set out the main similarities and the main differences between the two systems of Indian classical music, preferably in a comparative table.

Common trap: A table works best. Cover both similarities (raga, tala, shared roots in the Natyashastra and Sangita Ratnakara) and differences (influences, improvisation, compositions, instruments, gharanas, key composers).

SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper I (2006–12): Indian History & Culture — Indian art, music and dance forms

Model answer

10 marks · 100-word limit

Indian classical music divided into two streams around the thirteenth to fourteenth century: Hindustani in the north and Carnatic in the south. Both share a common grammar but differ in style and development.

Hindustani
  • Persian–Sufi influence
  • Long improvised alap
  • Gharanas of style
  • Tabla, sitar, sarod
vs
Carnatic
  • Rooted in devotional kriti
  • Composition-centred
  • No gharanas; shared bani
  • Mridangam, veena, violin
Hindustani vs Carnatic music

Similarities

  • Common base: Both rest on raga (melodic framework) and tala (rhythmic cycle) and trace their theory to Bharata's Natyashastra and Sharngadeva's Sangita Ratnakara.
  • Practice: Both use a drone, emphasise improvisation within rules and are transmitted through the guru–shishya tradition.

Differences

AspectHindustaniCarnatic
Region and influenceNorth India; absorbed Persian and Sufi elements in the Sultanate and Mughal courtsSouth India; developed largely within a devotional, temple-based setting
EmphasisImprovisation, with a slow alap openingFixed compositions (kriti), sung with gamaka ornamentation
Raga systemRagas classed by thaats; time of day mattersRagas classed by 72 melakartas
FormsDhrupad, khayal, thumri, tappaVarnam, kriti, padam, javali, tillana
InstrumentsTabla, sitar, sarod, shehnai, sarangiMridangam, veena, ghatam, violin, nadaswaram
Key figuresTansen, Amir Khusrau; gharanas such as Gwalior and KiranaThe Trinity: Tyagaraja, Muthuswami Dikshitar, Syama Sastri; Purandara Dasa

The two systems are branches of one tree: different in flavour, unified in grammar, and increasingly in dialogue through jugalbandis.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 187 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 100-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • NCERTNCERT, An Introduction to Indian Art (Class XI) — Indian music
  • BookNitin Singhania, Indian Art and Culture — Ch. on Indian music
  • OfficialCCRT (Centre for Cultural Resources and Training) — Indian classical music

More from GS Paper I (old) 2009

Q1(a)·15 marks·150 words·History
Critically analyse the following statement with reference to the context in which it was made: “Many Englishmen honestly consider themselves the trustees for India and yet to what a condition they have reduced our country.”
The statement is in the idiom of Gandhi (it is commonly attributed to him) and sums up the moral core of the nationalist case against British rule: individual…
Read the model answer →
Q1(b)·15 marks·150 words·History
Critically analyse the following statement with reference to the context in which it was made: “The foreign power will be withdrawn but for me real freedom will come only when we free ourselves of the dominance of western education, western culture and the…
Spoken as the end of British rule approached and reflecting Gandhi's long critique of modern civilisation (the attribution is usual but not certain), the statement…
Read the model answer →
Q1(c)·15 marks·150 words·History
Critically analyse the following statement with reference to the context in which it was made: “Satan cannot enter till he finds a flaw, …. A great ocean separates us educated few from the millions in our country.”
The statement, in Gandhi's voice (it is usually attributed to him and echoes his Banaras Hindu University speech of February 1916), makes two linked claims: foreign…
Read the model answer →
Q2(a)·2 marks·20 words·History
Write a short note on: Kiang Nongbah
U Kiang Nongbah was a Jaintia (Pnar) freedom fighter of present-day Meghalaya.
Read the model answer →
Q2(b)·2 marks·20 words·History
Write a short note on: Maski
Maski is an archaeological site in Raichur district, Karnataka.
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.