Comment critically on the following statement: “The lesson of the current global financial crisis is that India should halt and may be even reverse financial liberalisation.”
Assess what the 2008 crisis actually teaches India, test whether halting or reversing financial liberalisation follows from it, and take a reasoned position.
Common trap: Do not equate the crisis with liberalisation per se. A top answer shows that the crisis came from weak regulation of complex finance, that India's cautious sequencing helped it, and that the lesson is better regulation and calibrated opening, citing the Raghuram Rajan Committee.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): Indian Economy — banking, financial sector reforms and the impact of the global economy
Model answer
20 marks · 200-word limitThe crisis that broke with the collapse of Lehman Brothers in September 2008 exposed the dangers of lightly regulated securitisation, excessive leverage and shadow banking. India escaped the worst largely because it liberalised cautiously, but that is an argument for prudent reform, not for reversing it.
- Light-touch regulation in the West
- Leverage, subprime and securitisation
- Lehman collapse, credit freeze
- India hit via FII outflows and trade
- Lesson: regulate better, keep reforming
What the crisis showed
- Regulatory failure: Banks and investment firms in the US and UK took risks hidden in complex derivatives that regulators did not see or check.
- Transmission to India: India was hit through foreign portfolio outflows, a sharp fall in the rupee, tighter external credit and slowing exports, not through toxic assets in its banks.
Why India was relatively safe
- Calibrated opening: Capital-account convertibility was gradual, as advised by the Tarapore committees, with limits on short-term debt.
- Prudential regulation: The RBI raised risk weights and provisioning on real estate and consumer credit in 2005–07 and kept banks away from exotic products.
- Public ownership: The dominance of public-sector banks maintained depositor confidence when private finance froze elsewhere.
Why reversal would be wrong
- Financial deepening: India still needs a deep corporate bond market, long-term infrastructure finance and financial inclusion for millions of unbanked households.
- Efficiency: Competition and new instruments since 1991 lowered costs of capital and improved allocation, which a rollback would undo.
- Expert advice: The Raghuram Rajan Committee (2008) recommended "a hundred small steps" of continued reform with stronger regulation.
The right lessons
- Macro-prudential tools: Counter-cyclical capital and provisioning, oversight of systemically important institutions and better regulator coordination. (Later: the Financial Stability and Development Council was set up in 2010.)
- Sequencing: Open the capital account step by step, keep watch on short-term external debt, and protect consumers of financial products.
The lesson of the crisis is to liberalise with strong, adaptive regulation, not to halt. India's cautious, sequenced model worked; the task now is to deepen and widen finance safely so that it serves growth and inclusion.
Read more — sources
- OfficialPlanning Commission, Report of the Committee on Financial Sector Reforms (Raghuram Rajan), "A Hundred Small Steps" (2008)
- OfficialReserve Bank of India, Report on Currency and Finance and Annual Report 2008–09
- OfficialRBI, Report of the Committee on Fuller Capital Account Convertibility (Tarapore II, 2006)
More from GS Paper II (old) 2009
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.