“In the WTO negotiations over the years of the DOHA Round, India appears to be diluting its stand on agriculture issues to pursue perceived gains in services.” Critically examine this statement.
Set out India's agricultural and services interests in the Doha Round, test the charge of dilution against India's actual record up to 2009, and give a verdict.
Common trap: Weak answers repeat the statement. A strong answer cites Cancun (2003), the July 2008 collapse over the Special Safeguard Mechanism and the September 2009 Delhi mini-ministerial, distinguishes tone from substance, and concludes.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): International economic institutions — WTO and India's trade policy
Model answer
20 marks · 200-word limitThe Doha Development Agenda launched in 2001 promised to put developing countries at its centre. India's defensive interest is agriculture, which supports hundreds of millions of small farmers; its offensive interest is services, especially IT outsourcing (Mode 1) and movement of professionals (Mode 4). Critics suspect India of trading the first for the second.
- Food and livelihood security
- Special Products for poor farmers
- Special Safeguard Mechanism
- Cut rich-country subsidies
- Mode 1: IT and BPO exports
- Mode 4: movement of professionals
- Fewer visa and outsourcing curbs
- Recognition of qualifications
Evidence that India held firm
- Coalitions: At Cancun (2003) India and Brazil led the G-20 against US–EU subsidies, and India works in the G-33 for Special Products and safeguards.
- July 2008: The Geneva mini-ministerial collapsed largely because India (Kamal Nath) refused to accept a weak trigger for the Special Safeguard Mechanism against import surges.
- Achievements: The Hong Kong ministerial (2005) agreed to end farm export subsidies by 2013, partly due to developing-country pressure.
Basis of the charge of dilution
- Change of tone: After May 2009 the new government hosted a Delhi mini-ministerial (September 2009) to restart talks, read by critics as softening.
- Services push: India sought plurilateral services requests and Mode 4 gains while developed-country farm subsidies remained largely intact.
- Asymmetry: Critics argue that any deal cutting Indian tariffs on farm goods while the US and EU shift subsidies into the "green box" would hurt farmers.
Assessment
- Substance vs style: India has not formally given up Special Products or the SSM; its engagement is more conciliatory but its red lines on food security remain.
- Linkage: Gains in services are uncertain because Mode 4 depends on domestic immigration laws of rich countries, so trading farm concessions for them would be unwise.
The statement is only partly true: India's style has softened, not its substance. India should keep agriculture and services on separate tracks, defend food security through the G-33 and pursue services gains through bilateral agreements as well.
Read more — sources
- OfficialWTO, Doha Ministerial Declaration (2001) and Hong Kong Ministerial Declaration (2005)
- OfficialMinistry of Commerce and Industry, Annual Report 2008–09
- BookMinistry of Finance, Economic Survey 2008–09 — chapter on international trade
More from GS Paper II (old) 2009
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.