Geography may remain the same; history need not.
1800–2000 words, 200 marks. In the old pattern (2010) the candidate wrote ONE essay chosen from four topics. Graded on understanding of the topic, orderly arrangement of ideas and concise expression. An aphorism to interpret: geography (location, neighbours, resources) is a given, but history (relations, conflicts, choices) is made — so the past need not dictate the future.
Common trap: Weak essays describe India's physical geography or retell Partition. The top essay of 2010 reads 'history' as the record of human choices and argues that fixed neighbours can still become friends — Franco-German reconciliation, ASEAN, India–Bangladesh — while honestly admitting that geography shapes, though it does not decide, and that history can also be remade for the worse (26/11, 2008).
Essay brief
1800–2000 words · 125 marks- International reading: neighbours cannot be chosen, but relations with them can — enmity is a choice, not a geographical destiny (strongest reading for India and South Asia).
- Philosophical reading: a debate between geographical determinism (Montesquieu, Mackinder's 'heartland') and human agency — geography sets the stage, people write the play.
- Domestic reading: regions once poor or violent (Punjab after militancy, Mizoram after the 1986 accord) have rewritten their history despite unchanged terrain.
- Critical reading: even geography is not fixed — canals, climate change, rivers and technology alter it — and history can regress as well as progress.
Meaning: the given and the made
- Geography as location, borders, rivers, mountains, resources and neighbours — largely beyond human choice
- History as the sum of decisions by leaders and peoples — wars, treaties, trade, trust
- The line echoes the idea that 'you can change friends but not neighbours' (attributed to Atal Bihari Vajpayee)
Geography does shape history
- The Himalaya and the monsoon shaped Indian civilisation, invasions through the north-western passes and India's maritime outlook
- Shared rivers make cooperation unavoidable: the Indus Waters Treaty (1960) has survived three wars
- Landlocked Nepal and Bhutan, and Bangladesh almost surrounded by India, make India the pivot of South Asia
History rewritten: world examples
- France and Germany fought three wars in 70 years, then built the European Coal and Steel Community (1951) and the European Union
- ASEAN (1967) turned a region of conflict, including the Vietnam war years, into a zone of cooperation
- Japan and the United States moved from war in 1945 to close alliance; South Africa from apartheid to democracy (1994)
India's attempts to remake history
- Rajiv Gandhi's 1988 China visit and the 1993 and 1996 border peace agreements; Nathu La border trade reopened in 2006
- Lahore bus yatra and Lahore Declaration (1999); composite dialogue with Pakistan from 2004
- Gujral Doctrine (1996–97) of non-reciprocal generosity; Ganga Waters Treaty with Bangladesh (1996)
- Look East Policy (1991) reconnecting India with South-East Asia; SAARC (1985) and SAFTA (2004 agreement, in force 2006)
When history repeats instead
- Kargil (1999) followed Lahore; the Mumbai attacks of November 2008 froze the dialogue with Pakistan
- The unresolved boundary with China and memories of 1962 keep suspicion alive
- Santayana's warning: those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it — history changes only when lessons are learnt
Geography is not fully fixed either
- Suez (1869) and Panama (1914) canals changed the geography of trade
- Climate change, melting glaciers and sea-level rise threaten to redraw coasts and river flows
- Technology — ports, highways, pipelines, the internet — shrinks distance and turns barriers into bridges
What it takes to change history
- Leadership willing to take political risk for peace
- Economic interdependence: trade, connectivity and energy links that raise the cost of conflict
- People-to-people contact, cultural ties and civil society dialogue
- Institutions and treaties that outlast governments
Opening. Open with the Indus Waters Treaty: signed in 1960, it has survived the wars of 1965, 1971 and Kargil — proof that the rivers India and Pakistan share are fixed, but how they share them was a choice.
Body. Define the two terms; concede how geography shapes history; then show history rewritten in Europe and East Asia; then India's own efforts with China, Pakistan, Bangladesh and South-East Asia; then why history sometimes repeats.
Counter-view. Give a paragraph to the determinist view — some conflicts seem rooted in terrain, rivers and borders — and to the point that history can also be remade for the worse, as 26/11 showed.
Conclusion. Close by arguing that geography is a given and history a task: India cannot move its neighbours, but it can choose to make South Asia's next chapter one of connectivity rather than conflict. (Later: the India–Bangladesh Land Boundary Agreement was implemented in 2015 — a 1974 deal finally settled.)
- Indus Waters Treaty (1960), brokered by the World Bank — Shared geography managed through a durable treaty
- European Coal and Steel Community (1951) and the European Union — Historic enemies France and Germany rewriting history
- ASEAN (1967) — A conflict-ridden region turned cooperative
- Lahore Declaration (1999) and Kargil (1999) — History changed and then reversed within months
- Gujral Doctrine and Ganga Waters Treaty with Bangladesh (1996) — Generosity towards smaller neighbours
- Look East Policy (1991) — India reshaping its relations beyond the subcontinent
- Nathu La border trade reopened (2006) — India–China thaw across a fixed frontier
- Mizo Accord (1986) — A domestic insurgency ended by political choice
- “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” — George Santayana, The Life of Reason (1905)
- “You can change friends but not neighbours.” — Attributed to Atal Bihari Vajpayee
- Writing a geography or history lesson instead of an argument about choice
- Arguing pure determinism or pure free will without balance
- Using only India–Pakistan and ignoring global examples of reconciliation
- Forgetting that history can be remade for the worse too
More from Essay 2010
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.