Should a moratorium be imposed on all fresh mining in tribal areas of the country?
1800–2000 words, 200 marks. In the old pattern (2010) the candidate wrote ONE essay chosen from four topics. Graded on understanding of the topic, orderly arrangement of ideas and concise expression. A 'should' question: weigh the case for a blanket halt against the nation's mineral needs, and reach a reasoned answer — usually a conditional one.
Common trap: Weak essays either demand mining at any cost for growth or romanticise tribals as untouchable museum pieces. The top essay of 2010 uses Niyamgiri (MoEF's rejection of Vedanta's clearance, August 2010), the Fifth Schedule, PESA, the Samatha judgment and the Forest Rights Act, links mining to displacement and Left-wing extremism, and argues for consent and benefit-sharing rather than either a blanket ban or business as usual.
Essay brief
1800–2000 words · 125 marks- Rights reading: mining in Scheduled Areas has repeatedly violated constitutional protections, so a pause is needed until consent and rights laws are actually enforced.
- Development reading: India's coal, iron ore and bauxite lie mostly under tribal districts of Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh and Odisha; a blanket moratorium would stall power, steel and jobs.
- Balanced reading: not a blanket moratorium but a conditional one — no fresh mining without gram sabha consent, settled forest rights, real benefit-sharing and protected 'no-go' zones (strongest reading).
- Security reading: alienation from land and forests feeds the Maoist insurgency; how mining is done is now a question of internal security, not only of economics.
The context in 2010
- Scheduled Tribes are about 8.2% of the population (Census 2001), yet bear a far larger share of development-induced displacement
- Mineral-rich districts overlap with forests, tribal habitats and the Maoist-affected 'red corridor'
- Niyamgiri: in August 2010 the Environment Ministry rejected forest clearance for Vedanta's bauxite mine after the N. C. Saxena committee found violations of forest and tribal rights
- Illegal mining scandals, notably iron ore in Bellary (Karnataka) investigated by the Lokayukta
Constitutional and legal protections
- Fifth Schedule: Governor's powers and Tribes Advisory Councils for Scheduled Areas
- PESA, 1996: gram sabhas to be consulted on land acquisition and to have a say over minor minerals
- Samatha judgment (1997): the Supreme Court barred transfer of tribal land in Scheduled Areas of Andhra Pradesh to private mining firms
- Forest Rights Act, 2006 (rules 2008): individual and community rights must be settled before forest land is diverted
The case for a moratorium
- Large-scale displacement with poor rehabilitation; scholars such as Walter Fernandes estimate tens of millions displaced since 1947, a large share tribal
- 'Resource curse': mineral-rich districts remain among India's poorest in health, literacy and nutrition
- Ecological loss — forests, water sources and sacred hills like Niyamgiri for the Dongria Kondh
- Prime Minister Manmohan Singh called Naxalism the single biggest internal security challenge; land alienation is a core grievance
The case against a blanket ban
- Coal supplies over half of India's electricity; steel, aluminium and cement need iron ore, bauxite and limestone
- A ban would hurt state revenues and the very regions that need investment and jobs
- Tribal communities are not uniform; some want jobs, roads and schools that responsible projects can bring
- A ban may push mining underground into illegal operations
Reform rather than a freeze
- Free, prior and informed consent of gram sabhas, in line with PESA and the Forest Rights Act
- Benefit-sharing: the draft Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Bill of 2010 proposed sharing profits with affected people
- Go/no-go classification of dense forests for coal mining, as the Environment Ministry attempted in 2009–10
- Transparent auctions, strict monitoring of illegal mining and real rehabilitation with land-for-land where possible
Lessons from elsewhere
- Botswana's diamond revenues invested in public services show minerals need not be a curse
- Indigenous land-use agreements in Canada and Australia give communities a share and a veto in some cases
- Norway's sovereign fund model for keeping resource wealth for future generations
Opening. Open with the Dongria Kondh of Niyamgiri, for whom the hill is a god — and with the August 2010 decision that halted a mine there — then ask whether every tribal hill deserves the same pause.
Body. Set out the stakes and the legal protections; make the strongest case for a moratorium; then the strongest case against; then propose a reformed framework.
Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the developmental view that India cannot leave its coal and iron ore in the ground, and answer it with the argument that mining without consent is neither just nor, in Maoist-affected areas, even feasible.
Conclusion. Conclude that the answer is a conditional moratorium — no fresh mining without consent, settled rights and fair shares — so that minerals become a blessing for the people who live above them. (Later: in 2013 the Supreme Court asked the gram sabhas of Niyamgiri to decide, and all those consulted rejected the project; the MMDR Amendment Act, 2015 created District Mineral Foundations for affected areas.)
- Niyamgiri and the N. C. Saxena committee (2010) — Clearance rejected for violation of forest and tribal rights
- Samatha v. State of Andhra Pradesh (1997) — Tribal land in Scheduled Areas protected from private mining leases
- PESA, 1996 and Forest Rights Act, 2006 — Laws that a consent-based approach must enforce
- Bellary illegal iron-ore mining (Karnataka) — Cost of unregulated mining
- Dantewada attack on CRPF (April 2010) — Violence in the mineral belt and the security dimension
- Draft MMDR Bill (2010) — Proposal to share mining profits with local people
- Botswana's diamond-revenue model — Mineral wealth used for development
- “The earth provides enough to satisfy every man's needs, but not every man's greed.” — Attributed to Mahatma Gandhi
- “We do not inherit the earth from our ancestors; we borrow it from our children.” — Proverb (often attributed to Native American tradition)
- Treating 'tribal areas' as only an environmental issue and ignoring rights and security
- Ignoring India's real need for coal and minerals
- Not knowing the Fifth Schedule, PESA, Samatha and the Forest Rights Act
- Giving a yes or no without conditions or alternatives
More from Essay 2010
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.