Do you agree with the view that Israel is a 'natural ally' of India?
Take a clear position on whether Israel is a 'natural ally', giving the case for convergence and the constraints, and justify the verdict.
Common trap: Do not answer only yes. A strong answer shows the depth of defence, counter-terror and agriculture ties, then weighs Palestine, the Arab world, Iran, the Gulf diaspora and domestic opinion, and settles on 'strategic partner, not ally'.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — India's relations with West Asia
Model answer
12 marks · 150-word limitIndia recognised Israel in 1950 but established full diplomatic relations only in January 1992. The phrase 'natural ally' gained currency after National Security Adviser Brajesh Mishra, in 2003, spoke of democracies facing terrorism coming together. The idea has substance, but alliance overstates it.
- Defence: Phalcon AWACS, Barak, UAVs
- Counter-terrorism and intelligence
- Agriculture and water technology
- Space: TecSAR, RISAT-2 on PSLV
- Support for a Palestinian state
- Arab world and Gulf diaspora
- Ties with Iran
- Domestic opinion; non-alignment
Case for convergence
- Defence: Israel became a leading arms supplier: emergency supplies during Kargil (1999), Phalcon AWACS delivered from 2009, Barak missiles, and Heron and Searcher drones.
- Shared threats: Both face cross-border terrorism and cooperate on intelligence and homeland security, especially after 26/11.
- Technology: Drip irrigation and dairy know-how, and ISRO's PSLV launches of Israel's TecSAR (2008) and RISAT-2 (2009).
Why 'ally' overstates it
- Palestine: India recognised the State of Palestine in 1988 and continues to back a two-state solution.
- Wider West Asia: The Gulf supplies most of India's oil and hosts millions of Indian workers; Iran matters for Afghanistan and energy.
- Autonomy: India avoids formal alliances; Israel's earlier arms dealings with China also limit full trust.
I agree only partly: Israel is a natural strategic partner in defence, technology and counter-terrorism, but India's interests across West Asia rule out an alliance. India should keep ties with Israel and the Arab world on separate, independent tracks.
Read more — sources
- OfficialMinistry of External Affairs, India-Israel Bilateral Brief
- BookP.R. Kumaraswamy, India's Israel Policy (Columbia University Press, 2010)
- BookHarsh V. Pant, Contemporary Debates in Indian Foreign and Security Policy
More from GS Paper II (old) 2010
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.