EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2014GS Paper 2Q2 · 12.5 marksPolityModel answer

Though the federal principle is dominant in our Constitution and that principle is one of its basic features, but it is equally true that federalism under the Indian Constitution leans in favour of a strong Centre, a feature that militates against the concept of strong federalism. Discuss.

DirectiveDiscuss
Marks12.5
Word limit200
PaperGS Paper 2
What the examiner wants

Show both the federal features that make federalism part of the basic structure and the unitary features that tilt the balance to the Centre, then judge whether this tilt really undermines federalism or is a deliberate design for a diverse, newly independent nation.

Common trap: Many answers simply list unitary features. A top answer accepts that the tilt exists, explains why the framers chose it (Partition, princely states, planning), notes judicial checks such as S.R. Bommai, and argues that India's federalism is "holding together" and cooperative rather than weak.

SyllabusFunctions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein.

Model answer

12.5 marks · 200-word limit

The Constitution creates a dual polity with a written division of powers, yet Article 1 calls India a "Union of States" and avoids the word federation. K.C. Wheare called it "quasi-federal", and in S.R. Bommai (1994) the Supreme Court held federalism to be a basic feature while accepting that the Centre is more powerful.

Federal features
  • Dual polity, Seventh Schedule lists
  • Written, rigid Constitution
  • Independent judiciary as umpire
  • Rajya Sabha represents states
  • State ratification under Article 368(2)
vs
Tilt to a strong Centre
  • Parliament can redraw states (Art 3)
  • Residuary powers with Union (Art 248)
  • Emergency and Article 356
  • Governor and reserved bills
  • Centre dominates finances
Indian federalism: federal features vs centralising tilt

Why federalism is a basic feature

  • Division of powers: The Seventh Schedule distributes subjects among the Union, State and Concurrent Lists, and states have exclusive legislative and executive domains such as police and public order.
  • Rigidity and umpire: Amendments affecting federal provisions need ratification by half the state legislatures under Article 368(2), and the Supreme Court decides Centre-state disputes under Article 131.
  • Judicial protection: S.R. Bommai subjected Article 356 to judicial review and the floor test, making arbitrary dismissal of state governments harder.

Features that lean to the Centre

  • Territorial control: Under Article 3 Parliament can create, merge or rename states by simple majority; the state's view is only recommendatory, so India is an "indestructible Union of destructible states".
  • Legislative dominance: Residuary powers lie with the Union (Article 248), Parliament can legislate on State List subjects under Articles 249, 250 and 252, and Union law prevails in the Concurrent List (Article 254).
  • Emergency and executive control: Article 352 converts the system into a unitary one, Article 356 has been used over a hundred times, and Articles 256–257 and 365 let the Centre direct states.
  • Agents and services: Governors are appointed by the President and may reserve bills (Article 200), while All India Services (Article 312) are controlled by the Union.
  • Fiscal imbalance: The Centre collects the more buoyant taxes while states bear most spending responsibilities, so they depend on Finance Commission transfers (Article 280) and discretionary grants.

Does the tilt militate against federalism?

  • Deliberate design: The framers, scarred by Partition and the integration of over 500 princely states, chose a strong Centre for unity and planned development; Ambedkar said the Constitution could be both unitary and federal according to time and circumstances.
  • Evidence of misuse: Partisan use of Article 356 before 1994, politicised Governors and centrally sponsored schemes with rigid conditions have often weakened states, as the Sarkaria Commission noted.
  • Federal resilience: Linguistic reorganisation, coalition governments since 1989 and the rise of regional parties have strengthened the bargaining power of states in practice.

Indian federalism is a "holding together" federalism: a strong Centre was meant to protect unity, not to reduce states to administrative units. The way forward lies in the Sarkaria and Punchhi recommendations on Governors and Article 356, a stronger Inter-State Council and fair fiscal devolution, so that a strong Centre coexists with strong states in a cooperative federation.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 427 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 200-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 7, Federalism
  • OfficialReport of the Commission on Centre-State Relations (Sarkaria Commission), 1988
  • OfficialReport of the Commission on Centre-State Relations (Punchhi Commission), 2010
  • BookD.D. Basu, Introduction to the Constitution of India — Part on the Federal System

More from GS Paper 2 2014

Q1·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
Starting from inventing the 'basic structure' doctrine, the judiciary has played a highly proactive role in ensuring that India develops into a thriving democracy. In light of the statement, evaluate the role played by judicial activism in achieving the…
Judicial activism is the judiciary going beyond adjudicating disputes to actively protect rights and push other organs to fulfil constitutional duties. It began with…
Read the model answer →
Q3·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
The 'Powers, Privileges and Immunities of Parliament and its Members' as envisaged in Article 105 of the Constitution leave room for a large number of un-codified and un-enumerated privileges to continue. Assess the reasons for the absence of legal…
Article 105 (and Article 194 for state legislatures) gives freedom of speech in Parliament and immunity from court proceedings for anything said or any vote given. For…
Read the model answer →
Q4·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
What do you understand by the concept "freedom of speech and expression" ? Does it cover hate speech also ? Why do the films in India stand on a slightly different plane from other forms of expression ? Discuss.
Article 19(1)(a) guarantees every citizen the freedom of speech and expression, the lifeblood of democracy because it enables debate, dissent and accountability. It is…
Read the model answer →
Q5·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
Instances of President's delay in commuting death sentences has come under public debate as denial of justice. Should there be a time limit specified for the President to accept/reject such petitions ? Analyse.
Article 72 empowers the President to grant pardons, reprieves, respites and remissions or to commute sentences, including the death sentence; Article 161 gives…
Read the model answer →
Q6·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity, Governance
The size of the cabinet should be as big as governmental work justifies and as big as the Prime Minister can manage as a team. How far is the efficacy of a government then inversely related to the size of the cabinet ? Discuss.
The Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister wields real executive power under Article 74 and is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha under Article 75(3).…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.