EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2014GS Paper 2Q3 · 12.5 marksPolityModel answer

The 'Powers, Privileges and Immunities of Parliament and its Members' as envisaged in Article 105 of the Constitution leave room for a large number of un-codified and un-enumerated privileges to continue. Assess the reasons for the absence of legal codification of the 'parliamentary privileges'. How can this problem be addressed ?

DirectiveAssess
Marks12.5
Word limit200
PaperGS Paper 2
What the examiner wants

Weigh the reasons Parliament has avoided codifying its privileges under Article 105(3), judge how valid they are, and then suggest concrete ways to define and limit privileges without weakening Parliament's independence.

Common trap: Weak answers merely list privileges. The question has two parts: reasons for non-codification (fear of judicial review under Article 13, flexibility, sovereignty claims) and the remedy. A top answer cites Keshav Singh, M.S.M. Sharma and Raja Ram Pal, notes the post-44th Amendment wording, and proposes calibrated codification as in Australia.

SyllabusParliament and State legislatures—structure, functioning, conduct of business, powers & privileges and issues arising out of these.

Model answer

12.5 marks · 200-word limit

Article 105 (and Article 194 for state legislatures) gives freedom of speech in Parliament and immunity from court proceedings for anything said or any vote given. For all other privileges, Article 105(3) says they shall be those defined by Parliament by law and, until then, those existing before the 44th Amendment (1978), which in effect are the privileges of the British House of Commons as at 1950.

  1. Article 105(3): privileges left undefined
  2. Courts test privilege vs rights
  3. Fear: codified law reviewable under Article 13
  4. Uncertainty for press and citizens
  5. Minimal codification with safeguards
From uncodified privileges to a calibrated law

Why privileges remain uncodified

  • Fear of judicial review: A privilege law would be "law" under Article 13 and could be tested against Fundamental Rights, whereas uncodified privileges were held in M.S.M. Sharma (1959) to prevail over Article 19(1)(a).
  • Need for flexibility: Parliament argues that contempt of the House takes new forms and a closed list would leave it unable to protect its dignity and functioning.
  • Institutional pride: Presiding officers see the power to define contempt and punish as inherent to a sovereign legislature, and there is little political consensus to give it up.
  • Convention-based model: Like Westminster, Indian legislatures rely on precedent, the Committee of Privileges and Speaker's rulings rather than statute.

Problems created by non-codification

  • Clash with courts: The Keshav Singh reference (1964) saw the Uttar Pradesh Assembly and the Allahabad High Court in open confrontation over a privilege committal.
  • Chilling effect on the press: Journalists and citizens cannot know in advance what amounts to breach of privilege, and legislatures act as accuser and judge.
  • Immunity for corruption: In P.V. Narasimha Rao (1998), bribe-takers who voted were held immune under Article 105(2), a reading many found indefensible (overruled in Sita Soren, 2024).
  • Partial clarity: Raja Ram Pal (2007) upheld the expulsion of MPs in the cash-for-query case but held that the exercise of privileges is open to judicial review for illegality or violation of rights.

How the problem can be addressed

  • Calibrated codification: Enact a law defining core privileges needed for functioning, as the NCRWC recommended in 2002, leaving speech and voting immunity untouched.
  • Learn from abroad: Australia's Parliamentary Privileges Act, 1987 defines contempt narrowly and caps penalties, while the UK Joint Committee on Parliamentary Privilege (1999) also favoured legislation.
  • Procedural fairness: Give the person charged notice, a hearing and reasons, and limit punishment to what protects the House rather than its members' reputations.
  • Narrow the immunity: Make clear that bribery to influence a vote is not protected, since it is outside the legislative function.

Privileges exist to protect the independence of Parliament, not to place legislators above the law. A short, rights-compatible code with fair procedure would preserve that independence while ending the uncertainty that now pits legislatures against courts, the press and citizens.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 419 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 200-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 5, Legislature
  • OfficialNational Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (NCRWC), Report, 2002
  • BookM.N. Kaul and S.L. Shakdher, Practice and Procedure of Parliament
  • OfficialSupreme Court of India, Raja Ram Pal v. Hon'ble Speaker, Lok Sabha (2007) 3 SCC 184

More from GS Paper 2 2014

Q1·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
Starting from inventing the 'basic structure' doctrine, the judiciary has played a highly proactive role in ensuring that India develops into a thriving democracy. In light of the statement, evaluate the role played by judicial activism in achieving the…
Judicial activism is the judiciary going beyond adjudicating disputes to actively protect rights and push other organs to fulfil constitutional duties. It began with…
Read the model answer →
Q2·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
Though the federal principle is dominant in our Constitution and that principle is one of its basic features, but it is equally true that federalism under the Indian Constitution leans in favour of a strong Centre, a feature that militates against the…
The Constitution creates a dual polity with a written division of powers, yet Article 1 calls India a "Union of States" and avoids the word federation. K.C. Wheare…
Read the model answer →
Q4·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
What do you understand by the concept "freedom of speech and expression" ? Does it cover hate speech also ? Why do the films in India stand on a slightly different plane from other forms of expression ? Discuss.
Article 19(1)(a) guarantees every citizen the freedom of speech and expression, the lifeblood of democracy because it enables debate, dissent and accountability. It is…
Read the model answer →
Q5·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
Instances of President's delay in commuting death sentences has come under public debate as denial of justice. Should there be a time limit specified for the President to accept/reject such petitions ? Analyse.
Article 72 empowers the President to grant pardons, reprieves, respites and remissions or to commute sentences, including the death sentence; Article 161 gives…
Read the model answer →
Q6·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity, Governance
The size of the cabinet should be as big as governmental work justifies and as big as the Prime Minister can manage as a team. How far is the efficacy of a government then inversely related to the size of the cabinet ? Discuss.
The Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister wields real executive power under Article 74 and is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha under Article 75(3).…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.