EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2015GS Paper 2Q15 · 12.5 marksGovernanceModel answer

“If amendment bill to the Whistleblowers Act, 2011 tabled in the Parliament is passed, there may be no one left to protect.” Critically evaluate.

DirectiveCritically evaluate
Marks12.5
Word limit200
PaperGS Paper 2
What the examiner wants

Judge how far the statement is valid, setting out the Bill's provisions, the arguments for and against it, and reaching a balanced verdict.

Common trap: Candidates often describe the 2014 Act only. The question is about the 2015 Amendment Bill, so name its provisions (RTI-style exemptions, Official Secrets Act) and weigh security concerns against the chilling effect.

SyllabusImportant aspects of governance, transparency and accountability, e-governance- applications, models, successes, limitations, and potential; citizens charters, transparency & accountability and institutional and other measures.

Model answer

12.5 marks · 200-word limit

The Whistle Blowers Protection Act, 2014 grew out of the murder of NHAI engineer Satyendra Dubey in 2003 and the Law Commission's 179th Report (2001). Before it was brought into force, the Whistle Blowers Protection (Amendment) Bill, 2015, passed by the Lok Sabha on 13 May 2015, proposed to narrow what may be disclosed.

Act, 2014
  • Disclosure allowed despite Official Secrets Act
  • Competent authority examines the complaint
  • Identity of complainant protected
vs
Amendment Bill, 2015
  • Ten barred categories modelled on RTI Sec 8(1)
  • Official Secrets Act prevails
  • Government-authorised body decides if barred
  • No public interest override
2014 Act versus 2015 Amendment Bill

Why the statement has merit

  • Most corruption is barred: Barring anything covered by the Official Secrets Act, 1923, along with information on economic or strategic interests, commercial confidence, Cabinet papers or fiduciary relationships covers much of procurement and contracts, the very areas where Dubey and IOC officer S. Manjunath (2005) exposed wrongdoing.
  • No public interest test: Unlike Section 8(2) of the RTI Act, the Bill has no override where public interest outweighs harm, and, as PRS notes, no RTI-style appeal process.
  • Executive veto: A government-authorised authority, whose qualifications are unspecified, decides whether a disclosure is barred, letting the accused department screen complaints against itself.
  • Pre-existing weaknesses: Anonymous complaints are not entertained, the private sector is excluded, and false disclosures attract up to two years' imprisonment, deterring complainants.

The government's case

  • National security: Disclosures touching sovereignty, defence and foreign relations need safeguards, and the categories mirror exemptions Parliament already accepted in the RTI Act, 2005.
  • Misuse: Filters can prevent leaks of trade secrets and frivolous complaints.

Assessment

  • Balance: Barred information could be routed to a secure, independent channel such as the CVC or Lokpal, rather than being excluded, with the Second ARC's 4th Report (2007) on Ethics in Governance as a guide.
  • Since then: The Bill lapsed with the 16th Lok Sabha in 2019, and the 2014 Act has still not been brought into force.

The statement is largely valid: by importing RTI exemptions without a public interest override, the Bill would leave few disclosures protected. Security can be protected through secure, confidential channels; a whistle-blower law that excludes most corruption fails the purpose for which Satyendra Dubey died.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 313 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 200-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialThe Whistle Blowers Protection Act, 2014 and the Whistle Blowers Protection (Amendment) Bill, 2015
  • ReportPRS Legislative Research, Legislative Brief on the Whistle Blowers Protection (Amendment) Bill, 2015
  • ReportLaw Commission of India, 179th Report on Public Interest Disclosure and Protection of Informers, 2001
  • ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, 4th Report: Ethics in Governance, 2007

More from GS Paper 2 2015

Q1·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
Discuss the possible factors that inhibit India from enacting for its citizens a uniform civil code as provided for in the Directive Principles of State Policy.
Article 44 directs that the State shall endeavour to secure for citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India. Being a Directive Principle, it is…
Read the model answer →
Q2·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
The concept of cooperative federalism has been increasingly emphasised in recent years. Highlight the drawbacks in the existing structure and the extent to which cooperative federalism would answer the shortcomings.
India's Constitution creates a union of states with a strong Centre, which K.C. Wheare called quasi-federal. The replacement of the Planning Commission by NITI Aayog on…
Read the model answer →
Q3·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity, Governance
In absence of a well-educated and organized local level government system, ‘Panchayats’ and ‘Samitis’ have remained mainly political institutions and not effective instruments of governance. Critically discuss.
The 73rd Amendment (1992), in force from 24 April 1993, gave panchayats constitutional status in Part IX with a three-tier structure, elections every five years and 29…
Read the model answer →
Q4·12.5 marks·200 words·Governance, Polity
Khap Panchayats have been in the news for functioning as extra-constitutional authorities, often delivering pronouncements amounting to human rights violations. Discuss critically the actions taken by the legislative, executive and the judiciary to set the…
Khap panchayats are traditional caste or clan councils of western Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and Rajasthan with no legal sanction. Their diktats against same-gotra and…
Read the model answer →
Q5·12.5 marks·200 words·Polity
Resorting to ordinances has always raised concern on violation of the spirit of separation of powers doctrine. While noting the rationales justifying the power to promulgate ordinances, analyze whether the decisions of the Supreme Court on the issue have…
Article 123 lets the President, and Article 213 the Governor, promulgate an ordinance when the legislature is not in session and circumstances demand immediate action.…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.