EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2015GS Paper 4 (Ethics)QQ13 (Case Study) · 25 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: You are heading a district administration in a particular department.

DirectiveDiscuss
Marks25
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

Examine each listed option from both sides, merits and demerits, and then propose and justify a better course; listing options without weighing them falls short.

Common trap: Many answers jump straight to an inquiry against the predecessor. The question asks for vested interests, a balanced merit-demerit view of all four options, and an additional option; the best answers keep the children's access, public funds and heritage at the centre and avoid accusing anyone beyond what the facts suggest.

SyllabusProbity in Governance: Concept of public service; Philosophical basis of governance and probity; Information sharing and transparency in government, Right to Information, Codes of Ethics, Codes of Conduct, Citizen's Charters, Work culture, Quality of service delivery, Utilization of public funds, challenges of corruption.

The case

You are heading a district administration in a particular department. Your senior officer calls you from the State Headquarters and tells you that a plot in Rampur village is to have a building constructed on it for a school. A visit is scheduled during which he will visit the site along with the chief engineer and the senior architect. He wants you to check out all the papers relating to it and to ensure that the visit is properly arranged. You examine the file which relates to the period before you joined the department. The land was acquired from the local Panchayat at a nominal cost and the papers show that clearance certificates are available from the two of the three authorities who have to certify the site’s suitability. There is no certification by the architect available on file. You decide to visit Rampur to ensure that all is in order as stated on file. When you visit Rampur, you find that the plot under reference is part of Thakurgarh Fort and that the walls, ramparts, etc., are running across it. The fort is well away from the main village, therefore a school here will be a serious inconvenience for the children. However, the area near the village has potential to expand into a larger residential area. The development charges on the existing plot, at the fort, will be very high and the question of heritage site has not been addressed. Moreover, the Sarpanch, at the time of acquisition of the land, was a relative of your predecessor. The whole transaction appears to have been done with some vested interest. (a) List the likely vested interests of the concerned parties. (b) Some of the options for action available to you are listed below. Discuss the merits and demerits of each of the options: (i) You can await the visit of the superior officer and let him take a decision. (ii) You can seek his advice in writing or on phone. (iii) You can consult your predecessor/colleagues, etc., and then decide what to do. (iv) You can find out if any alternate plot can be got in exchange and then send a comprehensive written report. Can you suggest any other option with proper justification?

Model answer

25 marks · 250-word limit

The case is a classic file-versus-field gap: papers that look complete hide an unsuitable site inside Thakurgarh Fort, a missing architect's certificate, an unexamined heritage question and a conflict of interest. The officer's duty is to put the facts honestly before the decision-maker, not to manage the visit cosmetically.

On file
  • Land acquired at nominal cost
  • Two of three clearances
  • Ready for school construction
vs
On the ground
  • Plot inside Thakurgarh Fort
  • Far from village, inconvenient for children
  • High development cost, heritage issue open
  • No architect certificate; Sarpanch related to predecessor
What the file says vs what the site shows

(a) Likely vested interests

PartyLikely vested interest
PredecessorFavouring a relative; possible personal gain from the deal
Then Sarpanch and relativesOff-loading land of little use while keeping land near the village, which can gain value as a residential area
Contractors and suppliersHigh development charges mean larger and more lucrative contracts
Certifying authoritiesClearances given casually or under influence, without real site inspection
Local land interestsKeeping the land near the village free for private development

(b) Merits and demerits of the options

OptionMeritsDemerits
(i) Await the visit and let the senior decideDecision rests with the competent authority, who sees the site himselfAbdicates responsibility; senior arrives unbriefed; the visit may become a formality
(ii) Seek advice in writing or on phoneSenior is alerted in advance; a written record protects bothPhone advice leaves no record; asking without offering a solution is passive
(iii) Consult predecessor and colleaguesGives background and institutional memoryPredecessor has a conflict of interest; risk of being pressured or of the matter leaking
(iv) Find an alternate plot and send a comprehensive reportSolution-oriented; serves children's interest; shows initiativeTakes time; exchange of land needs Panchayat and higher approvals, and may not be possible before the visit

Another option: report now, propose, and verify

  • Immediate written report: Send the senior officer, before the visit, a factual note with photographs on the fort walls, the distance from the village, the missing architect certificate and the heritage question.
  • Alternatives on the table: Identify possible plots near the expanding residential area and include them in the visit itinerary along with the fort site.
  • Heritage check: Seek the view of the State archaeology department and, if the fort is centrally protected, the Archaeological Survey of India, since construction near protected monuments is restricted under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958.
  • Accountability: Recommend a fact-finding or vigilance inquiry into the acquisition, without prejudging anyone.

Justification

  • Values: Integrity, objectivity and courage to report inconvenient facts; the best interest of children, who need a school within reach under the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009.
  • Public funds: Avoids wasteful expenditure and possible damage to heritage.

The right course combines option (iv) with prompt written disclosure: inform the superior early, offer a workable alternative and leave the decision to him with full facts. A school is meant to serve children for decades; choosing its site honestly matters more than smoothing one inspection visit.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 437 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialAncient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958 (amended 2010)
  • OfficialRight of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009
  • OfficialAll India Services (Conduct) Rules, 1968
  • ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission — 4th Report, Ethics in Governance (2007)

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2015

QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What is meant by ‘environmental ethics’? Why is it important to study? Discuss any one environmental issue from the viewpoint of environmental ethics.
Environmental ethics is the branch of applied ethics that asks what duties humans owe to nature — other species, ecosystems and future generations — and whether nature…
Read the model answer →
QQ1(b)·10 marks·200 words·Ethics
Differentiate between the following: (i) Law and Ethics (ii) Ethical management and Management of ethics (iii) Discrimination and Preferential treatment (iv) Personal ethics and Professional ethics
Ethics in public life works at several levels — rule and value, individual and institution. The four pairs below look alike but differ in source, scope and sanction.
Read the model answer →
QQ2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Given are two quotations of moral thinkers/philosophers. For each of these, bring out what it means to you in the present context: “The weak can never forgive; forgiveness is the attribute of the strong.”
Gandhi made this remark in a press interview in Karachi after the execution of Bhagat Singh, published in Young India on 2 April 1931. Forgiveness, for him, is not…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Given are two quotations of moral thinkers/philosophers. For each of these, bring out what it means to you in the present context: “We can easily forgive a child who is afraid of the dark; the real tragedy of life is when men are afraid of the light.”
This line is popularly attributed to Plato but cannot be found in his writings; its spirit echoes his Allegory of the Cave in the Republic, where prisoners prefer…
Read the model answer →
QQ3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
“A mere compliance with law is not enough, the public servant also has to have a well-developed sensibility to ethical issues for effective discharge of duties.” Do you agree? Explain with the help of two examples, where (i) an act is ethically right, but…
Law prescribes the minimum standard of conduct; ethics guides the vast area where law is silent, outdated or unjust. The Nolan Committee's Seven Principles of Public…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.