EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2015GS Paper 4 (Ethics)QQ12 (Case Study) · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: There is a disaster-prone State having frequent landslides, forest fires, cloudbursts, flash floods and earthquakes, etc.

DirectiveJustify
Marks20
Word limit200
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

Give the order of rescue and defend each choice with reasons, principles and consequences; a bare list without reasons does not answer the question.

Common trap: Weak answers either rescue the VIPs first to please superiors or rank groups mechanically. Strong answers state a clear principle (triage by threat and vulnerability), recognise the State's special duty to locked-in prisoners and to patients, and show how VIPs are handled without discourtesy.

SyllabusAttitude and foundational values for Civil Service, integrity, impartiality and non-partisanship, objectivity, dedication to public service, empathy, tolerance and compassion towards the weaker-sections.

The case

There is a disaster-prone State having frequent landslides, forest fires, cloudbursts, flash floods and earthquakes, etc. Some of these are seasonal and often unpredictable. The magnitude of the disaster is always unanticipated. During one of the seasons, a cloudburst caused devastating floods and landslides leading to high casualties. There was major damage to infrastructure like roads, bridges and power generating units. This led to more than 100000 pilgrims, tourists and other locals trapped across different routes and locations. The people trapped in your area of responsibility included senior citizens, patients in hospitals, women and children, hikers, tourists, ruling party’s regional president along with his family, additional chief secretary of the neighbouring State and prisoners in jail. As a civil services officer of the State, what would be the order in which you would rescue these people and why? Give justifications.

Model answer

20 marks · 200-word limit

Disaster rescue is a test of impartiality under pressure. Section 61 of the Disaster Management Act, 2005 bars discrimination in relief on grounds of sex, caste, community, descent or religion, and the guiding principle in the field is triage: those whose lives are most immediately at risk, and who are least able to save themselves, come first.

  1. Hospital patients and the critically injured
  2. Senior citizens, women and children
  3. Stranded hikers, tourists and pilgrims
  4. Prisoners, moved under guard
  5. Able-bodied VIPs, treated like any citizen
Rescue priority: need and vulnerability, not status

Guiding principles

  • Triage: Priority depends on the threat to life and on how far a person can help himself, not on rank or influence.
  • Equality before law: Article 14 and the right to life under Article 21 extend to every trapped person, including prisoners.
  • Parallel action: Different teams (NDRF, police, SDRF, medical) work simultaneously; the order guides the allocation of scarce helicopters, boats and stretchers.

Order of rescue and justification

PriorityGroupJustification
1Patients in hospitalsLives depend on power, oxygen and medicines; evacuate the critical to safer hospitals first, with medical staff.
2Senior citizens, women (especially pregnant women) and childrenLow mobility and high vulnerability to cold, hunger and injury; children must not be separated from parents.
3Hikers, tourists and pilgrimsOften stranded in exposed, unfamiliar terrain without food or shelter; hikers in remote spots need specialised air or mountain teams.
4Prisoners in jailLocked in and unable to escape, so the State owes them a special duty; shift them under escort to a safe jail if the building is threatened.
5Ruling party's regional president and family; additional chief secretary of the neighbouring StateAble-bodied adults are rescued by need like others; family members who are elderly, ill or children go with groups 1 and 2.

Handling the VIP dimension

  • No political pressure: Courteously explain to the party leader that rescue follows need; offer relief camp shelter, food and communication meanwhile.
  • Use their capacities: The additional chief secretary can help coordinate with his own State, which is likely to have its own residents among the stranded.
  • Transparency: Publish lists of rescued and missing persons and the evacuation schedule to curb rumours and charges of favouritism.

Supporting steps

  • Command and communication: Activate the incident response system, set up satellite phones and a control room, and coordinate with the Army and Air Force.
  • Relief: Food, water, medicines, temporary shelters and trauma counselling at every stranded point until evacuation.

A civil servant's duty in a disaster is to save the most lives with limited means, guided by compassion and impartiality. Treating the leader and the senior officer like any other citizen is not discourtesy; it is the strongest assurance to every trapped person that the State values each life equally.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 414 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 200-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialDisaster Management Act, 2005
  • OfficialNational Disaster Management Guidelines — Incident Response System (NDMA)
  • ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission — 3rd Report, Crisis Management (2006)

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2015

QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What is meant by ‘environmental ethics’? Why is it important to study? Discuss any one environmental issue from the viewpoint of environmental ethics.
Environmental ethics is the branch of applied ethics that asks what duties humans owe to nature — other species, ecosystems and future generations — and whether nature…
Read the model answer →
QQ1(b)·10 marks·200 words·Ethics
Differentiate between the following: (i) Law and Ethics (ii) Ethical management and Management of ethics (iii) Discrimination and Preferential treatment (iv) Personal ethics and Professional ethics
Ethics in public life works at several levels — rule and value, individual and institution. The four pairs below look alike but differ in source, scope and sanction.
Read the model answer →
QQ2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Given are two quotations of moral thinkers/philosophers. For each of these, bring out what it means to you in the present context: “The weak can never forgive; forgiveness is the attribute of the strong.”
Gandhi made this remark in a press interview in Karachi after the execution of Bhagat Singh, published in Young India on 2 April 1931. Forgiveness, for him, is not…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Given are two quotations of moral thinkers/philosophers. For each of these, bring out what it means to you in the present context: “We can easily forgive a child who is afraid of the dark; the real tragedy of life is when men are afraid of the light.”
This line is popularly attributed to Plato but cannot be found in his writings; its spirit echoes his Allegory of the Cave in the Republic, where prisoners prefer…
Read the model answer →
QQ3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
“A mere compliance with law is not enough, the public servant also has to have a well-developed sensibility to ethical issues for effective discharge of duties.” Do you agree? Explain with the help of two examples, where (i) an act is ethically right, but…
Law prescribes the minimum standard of conduct; ethics guides the vast area where law is silent, outdated or unjust. The Nolan Committee's Seven Principles of Public…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.