EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2016EssayTopic 2 · 125 marksModel answer

Need brings greed, if greed increases it spoils breed.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. A proverb-like topic with a chain: need, greed, then the spoiling of "breed". Interpret "breed" clearly — the next generation, the species, the character of a people.

Common trap: Most essays write on greed in general. The best ones follow the chain the topic sets out: legitimate need can slide into greed, and greed then corrupts what we pass on — the environment, social values, even the genetic and cultural stock. Defining the line between need and greed is the intellectual heart of this essay.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Ethical reading: satisfying needs builds a habit of acquiring, which grows into greed; greed then corrupts character and is passed on as values to the next generation.
  • Ecological reading: human need turned into greed degrades the earth — forests, soil, water — and spoils the inheritance of future generations (strongest and most concrete reading).
  • Social reading: greed in elites — corruption, crony capitalism — spoils the "breed" of institutions and teaches a society that dishonesty pays.
  • Counter-reading: need is not the cause of greed; ambition can be productive, and the line between need and greed is drawn by values and institutions, not fate.
Dimensions to cover

Need and greed

  • Need: food, shelter, dignity — legitimate and finite
  • Greed: desire beyond need, never satisfied
  • Indian traditions — aparigraha (Jainism), santosh (Yoga sutras), tanha (Buddhism) — warn against the slide

How need becomes greed

  • Scarcity and insecurity breed hoarding
  • Consumer culture turns wants into needs through advertising
  • Comparison and status: wealth measured against others

Spoiling the ecological breed

  • Pesticide overuse in Punjab's Malwa belt and associated health fears
  • Overfishing and sand mining exhausting resources
  • Endosulfan tragedy in Kasaragod, Kerala: harm passing to children

Spoiling the social breed

  • Corruption scams teaching the young that dishonesty pays
  • Dowry as greed corrupting family and gender relations
  • The 2008 global financial crisis: greed spreading risk across generations

Counter-view

  • Ambition and profit motive drive innovation and growth
  • Need for many is still unmet — calling poor people's demands greed is unjust
  • Institutions, not human nature alone, decide whether greed spreads

Curbing greed

  • Gandhi's trusteeship: wealth held in trust for society
  • Regulation, transparency and accountability (RTI, Lokpal)
  • Education in values and sustainable consumption (Mission LiFE, later)
Structure

Opening. Open with an image — a family that dug one borewell for need, then a second to sell water, and then watched the village wells run dry for their grandchildren.

Body. Follow the chain the topic gives: from need, to greed, to the spoiling of breed — ecological, social, institutional — with Indian and global examples at each step.

Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the counter-view: ambition is not greed, and the poor's demands are need. Show where the line lies.

Conclusion. Close with Gandhi's distinction between need and greed and the idea of trusteeship — and return to the borewell, imagined as a shared village resource.

Examples to use
  • Endosulfan tragedy, Kasaragod (Kerala) — Harm that passed to the next generation
  • 2008 global financial crisis — Greed in finance with global, long-term costs
  • Satyam accounting scandal (2009) — Corporate greed corrupting institutional trust
  • Groundwater depletion in Punjab and Rajasthan — Ecological breed spoiled by over-use
  • Rashtriya Gokul Mission (2014) — Effort to save indigenous cattle breeds — a literal reading of "breed"
  • Panama Papers (2016) — Greed among elites hidden from public scrutiny
Quotes
  • “The world has enough for everyone's need, but not enough for everyone's greed.” — Mahatma Gandhi
Pitfalls
  • Ignoring the word "breed", which is the topic's conclusion
  • Moralising against all desire, including legitimate need and ambition
  • Writing only about corruption

More from Essay 2016

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.