Need brings greed, if greed increases it spoils breed.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. A proverb-like topic with a chain: need, greed, then the spoiling of "breed". Interpret "breed" clearly — the next generation, the species, the character of a people.
Common trap: Most essays write on greed in general. The best ones follow the chain the topic sets out: legitimate need can slide into greed, and greed then corrupts what we pass on — the environment, social values, even the genetic and cultural stock. Defining the line between need and greed is the intellectual heart of this essay.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Ethical reading: satisfying needs builds a habit of acquiring, which grows into greed; greed then corrupts character and is passed on as values to the next generation.
- Ecological reading: human need turned into greed degrades the earth — forests, soil, water — and spoils the inheritance of future generations (strongest and most concrete reading).
- Social reading: greed in elites — corruption, crony capitalism — spoils the "breed" of institutions and teaches a society that dishonesty pays.
- Counter-reading: need is not the cause of greed; ambition can be productive, and the line between need and greed is drawn by values and institutions, not fate.
Need and greed
- Need: food, shelter, dignity — legitimate and finite
- Greed: desire beyond need, never satisfied
- Indian traditions — aparigraha (Jainism), santosh (Yoga sutras), tanha (Buddhism) — warn against the slide
How need becomes greed
- Scarcity and insecurity breed hoarding
- Consumer culture turns wants into needs through advertising
- Comparison and status: wealth measured against others
Spoiling the ecological breed
- Pesticide overuse in Punjab's Malwa belt and associated health fears
- Overfishing and sand mining exhausting resources
- Endosulfan tragedy in Kasaragod, Kerala: harm passing to children
Spoiling the social breed
- Corruption scams teaching the young that dishonesty pays
- Dowry as greed corrupting family and gender relations
- The 2008 global financial crisis: greed spreading risk across generations
Counter-view
- Ambition and profit motive drive innovation and growth
- Need for many is still unmet — calling poor people's demands greed is unjust
- Institutions, not human nature alone, decide whether greed spreads
Curbing greed
- Gandhi's trusteeship: wealth held in trust for society
- Regulation, transparency and accountability (RTI, Lokpal)
- Education in values and sustainable consumption (Mission LiFE, later)
Opening. Open with an image — a family that dug one borewell for need, then a second to sell water, and then watched the village wells run dry for their grandchildren.
Body. Follow the chain the topic gives: from need, to greed, to the spoiling of breed — ecological, social, institutional — with Indian and global examples at each step.
Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the counter-view: ambition is not greed, and the poor's demands are need. Show where the line lies.
Conclusion. Close with Gandhi's distinction between need and greed and the idea of trusteeship — and return to the borewell, imagined as a shared village resource.
- Endosulfan tragedy, Kasaragod (Kerala) — Harm that passed to the next generation
- 2008 global financial crisis — Greed in finance with global, long-term costs
- Satyam accounting scandal (2009) — Corporate greed corrupting institutional trust
- Groundwater depletion in Punjab and Rajasthan — Ecological breed spoiled by over-use
- Rashtriya Gokul Mission (2014) — Effort to save indigenous cattle breeds — a literal reading of "breed"
- Panama Papers (2016) — Greed among elites hidden from public scrutiny
- “The world has enough for everyone's need, but not enough for everyone's greed.” — Mahatma Gandhi
- Ignoring the word "breed", which is the topic's conclusion
- Moralising against all desire, including legitimate need and ambition
- Writing only about corruption
More from Essay 2016
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.