Water disputes between states in federal India.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. A descriptive-sounding topic that needs an argument: explain why disputes persist and how federal institutions can resolve them.
Common trap: The weak essay lists every river dispute. The strong one explains the structure — water in the State List but inter-state rivers under Union power, tribunals that take decades, awards that are resisted — then uses two or three disputes in depth and argues for basin-level cooperation and data transparency rather than adversarial litigation.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Constitutional reading: disputes reflect the federal design — Entry 17 of the State List, Entry 56 of the Union List and Article 262 — and its weak enforcement.
- Political reading: water has become an identity issue; governments gain votes by refusing to share, which turns technical problems into emotional conflicts (strongest explanatory reading).
- Resource reading: rising demand, groundwater depletion and climate variability have made water scarcer, so disputes are symptoms of a deeper crisis.
- Cooperative reading: the solution lies in shared basin management, data sharing and demand reduction, not in winning tribunal battles.
The constitutional design
- Water a State subject (Entry 17), subject to Union regulation of inter-state rivers (Entry 56)
- Article 262 and the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 (amended 2002)
- River Boards Act, 1956, largely unused
Major disputes
- Cauvery: Karnataka and Tamil Nadu (with Kerala and Puducherry) — tribunal award 2007, Supreme Court verdict 2018
- Krishna, Godavari, Mahadayi and the Ravi–Beas/SYL canal dispute
- Mullaperiyar dam between Kerala and Tamil Nadu — Supreme Court rulings of 2006 and 2014
Why they persist
- Tribunals take decades; awards are delayed in notification and resisted
- Lack of trusted, shared data on flows and use
- Political mobilisation and agitations during dry years
Deeper causes
- Water-intensive crops in water-scarce regions
- Groundwater depletion making surface water more contested
- Climate change making monsoon flows erratic
Counter-view
- Despite disputes, most inter-state water sharing works quietly
- Courts and tribunals have eventually produced binding settlements
- Interlinking projects like Ken–Betwa show cooperation is possible
Way forward
- A permanent tribunal and time limits, as proposed in the Inter-State River Water Disputes (Amendment) Bill, 2019
- Basin authorities like the Cauvery Water Management Authority (2018)
- Mihir Shah Committee (2016) on restructuring water institutions; demand management and micro-irrigation
Opening. Open with a dry September in the Cauvery basin — buses halted at the Karnataka–Tamil Nadu border while farmers on both sides watch the same river.
Body. Explain the federal framework first, then take two disputes in depth, then the reasons they persist and the deeper resource crisis beneath them.
Counter-view. Give a paragraph to the view that the system works more than headlines suggest, with examples of cooperation.
Conclusion. Close with a vision of rivers managed as shared basins, not borders — water as a bond of federalism rather than a wedge. Return to the river at the border.
- Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal (award 2007) and Supreme Court judgment (2018) — The classic case; 2018 is after the exam — mark it
- Mullaperiyar dam dispute and Supreme Court rulings (2006, 2014) — Safety and water-sharing intertwined
- Sutlej–Yamuna Link canal — A decades-old award still unimplemented
- Narmada Water Disputes Tribunal (1979) — A tribunal award that did get implemented
- Indus Waters Treaty (1960) — International proof that even hostile neighbours can share rivers
- Mekong River Commission — Basin-level cooperation model
- Mihir Shah Committee (2016) — Institutional reform proposals
- “When the well is dry, we know the worth of water.” — Benjamin Franklin, Poor Richard's Almanack
- “Rahiman paani raakhiye, bin paani sab soon.” — Rahim
- Listing every dispute with no argument
- Ignoring the constitutional framework that shapes the disputes
- Proposing only "interlink all rivers" without discussing its ecological costs
More from Essay 2016
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.