The terms 'Hot Pursuit' and 'Surgical Strikes' are often used in connection with armed action against terrorist attacks. Discuss the strategic impact of such actions.
Explain the concepts and then weigh their strategic consequences from several angles, positive and negative, with examples.
Common trap: Weak answers just narrate the September 2016 strikes. A top answer first separates the two terms, uses both Indian cases (Myanmar 2015, LoC 2016), and then weighs deterrence, escalation, diplomatic and legal effects in a balanced way.
SyllabusRole of external state and non-state actors in creating challenges to internal security.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitHot pursuit is the chase of fleeing attackers across a border soon after an attack; a surgical strike is a pre-planned, limited and precise raid on specific targets with minimal collateral damage. India used the first idea against NSCN(K) in Myanmar on 9 June 2015 and the second across the LoC on the night of 28-29 September 2016.
- Reactive, immediate chase
- Continuous from the attack
- Recognised at sea (UNCLOS Art. 111)
- Contested on land
- Pre-planned, intelligence-led
- Precise targets, quick withdrawal
- Justified as self-defence (UN Charter Art. 51)
- Calibrated to limit escalation
Indian and global instances
- Myanmar, June 2015: After the Chandel ambush of 4 June 2015 killed 18 soldiers of 6 Dogra, special forces struck insurgent camps inside Myanmar on 9 June.
- LoC, September 2016: Following the Uri attack of 18 September 2016 that killed 19 soldiers, the Army hit terrorist launch pads across the LoC and the DGMO publicly announced it.
- Abroad: The US raid on Abbottabad in 2011 and Israeli strikes on militant targets show the same model of limited, deniable or announced action.
Positive strategic impact
- Restoring deterrence: Raising the cost of cross-border terrorism signals that sponsors cannot shelter behind the border or a nuclear threshold.
- Doctrinal shift: India moved from strategic restraint after the 2001 Parliament and 2008 Mumbai attacks to calibrated punitive response.
- Morale and credibility: They reassure the forces and public and show that the state can retaliate without full-scale war.
Limitations and risks
- Escalation: Against a nuclear-armed Pakistan each strike carries a risk of a retaliatory spiral and ceasefire breakdown along the LoC.
- Limited lasting effect: Camps relocate and infiltration and attacks resumed on the LoC after September 2016, so strikes alone do not end proxy war.
- Diplomatic and legal costs: Strikes need host-state cooperation (Myanmar) or global acceptance; Pakistan denied the 2016 strike, and public boasting can weaken quiet cooperation with neighbours.
Such actions are a useful instrument of coercive diplomacy, not a strategy in themselves. Their value lies in being credible, calibrated and rare, backed by intelligence, border sealing, diplomatic isolation of sponsors and terror-finance pressure.
Read more — sources
- OfficialMinistry of Defence / DGMO press statement on the LoC strikes, 29 September 2016
- OfficialCharter of the United Nations, Article 51; UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982), Article 111
- BookAshok Kumar and Vipul Anekant, Challenges to Internal Security of India
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 3 2016
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.