EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2016GS Paper 4 (Ethics)QQ11 (Case Study) · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: Suppose you are an officer in-charge of implementing a social service scheme to provide support to old and destitute women.

DirectiveCan you think of a rational way / Give your reasons
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

Part (a) asks for a practical, lawful solution that dissolves the false choice; part (b) asks you to justify it with ethical, constitutional and administrative reasons.

Common trap: The trap is to choose one horn of the dilemma, either breaking the rules out of sympathy or rejecting her. A top answer shows how eligibility can be proved by other legitimate means, gives interim relief, and addresses the systemic exclusion.

SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Attitude and foundational values for Civil Service: integrity, impartiality and non-partisanship, objectivity, dedication to public service, empathy, tolerance and compassion towards the weaker sections; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance.)

The case

Suppose you are an officer in-charge of implementing a social service scheme to provide support to old and destitute women. An old and illiterate woman comes to you to avail the benefits of the scheme. However, she has no documents to show that she fulfils the eligibility criteria. But after meeting her and listening to her you feel that she certainly needs support. Your enquiries also show that she is really destitute and living in a pitiable condition. You are in a dilemma as to what to do. Putting her under the scheme without necessary documents would clearly be violation of rules. But denying her the support would be cruel and inhuman. (a) Can you think of a rational way to resolve this dilemma? (b) Give your reasons for it.

Model answer

20 marks · 250-word limit

Article 41 of the Constitution directs the State to provide public assistance in old age and undeserved want. Documents exist to prevent fraud, not to exclude the very people a welfare scheme is meant for. The rational way out is to satisfy the purpose of the rule through other reliable proof, rather than either break the rule or abandon her.

False choice
  • Enrol without proof: rule broken, bad precedent
  • Reject her: lawful but cruel
  • Both ignore the scheme's purpose
vs
Rational resolution
  • Verify eligibility through other evidence
  • Help her get the missing documents
  • Immediate relief from other sources
  • Flag the gap for rule reform
Two wrong answers and the rational middle path

(a) A rational way to resolve the dilemma

  • Verify through alternative evidence: Record my field enquiry formally, and obtain written certification from the sarpanch or ward member, neighbours' statements, a medical assessment of age, or a self-declaration where the rules permit it.
  • Help her obtain documents: Assign staff to get her an Aadhaar number (UIDAI allows enrolment through an introducer for people without documents), a bank account and any age or income certificate, ideally through a camp so others like her are also covered.
  • Seek a lawful relaxation: Put up the case with my enquiry report to the competent authority, asking for provisional sanction or a relaxation of documentary requirements if the rules allow.
  • Immediate relief meanwhile: Link her to other support she can get at once: food grains under the public distribution system or the Annapurna scheme, a shelter home, or help from the district Red Cross or NGOs.
  • Fix the system: Report to higher authorities that documentation rules are excluding genuine beneficiaries, and suggest acceptance of verification by local officials as standard practice.

(b) Reasons for this approach

PrincipleHow the approach satisfies it
Rule of lawNo rule is broken; eligibility is established, only the form of proof differs
Spirit over letterRules serve the purpose of reaching the destitute; meeting that purpose honours the rule
Compassion and dignityShe is treated as a person with rights, not a file; Kant's idea of treating people as ends
AccountabilityA written record of enquiry and approval protects both the officer and public money
EquityThe camp and the system report help every similar woman, not only the one before me
  • Gandhi's talisman: An officer should ask whether the step will help the poorest person they have seen; refusing an illiterate destitute woman for want of papers fails that test.
  • Citizen-centric administration: The Second Administrative Reforms Commission's Twelfth Report (2009) urged administration designed around the citizen's needs, and the government's 2014 move towards self-attestation shows paperwork can be eased without loss of control.

Compassion without rules invites misuse; rules without compassion defeat their own purpose. The officer's job is to make the system work for the person it was built for, by verifying need through enquiry, completing the paperwork for her, and reforming rules that keep the poorest out.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 421 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialConstitution of India — Article 41 (Directive Principles of State Policy)
  • OfficialNational Social Assistance Programme (1995) guidelines, Ministry of Rural Development
  • ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, Twelfth Report: Citizen Centric Administration (2009)

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2016

QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Explain how ethics contributes to social and human well-being.
Ethics is the study of what is right and good in human conduct. For Aristotle the end of ethical life is eudaimonia, human flourishing, and a flourishing person can…
Read the model answer →
QQ1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Why should impartiality and non-partisanship be considered as foundational values in public services, especially in the present day socio-political context? Illustrate your answer with examples.
Impartiality means treating every citizen equally, without bias of caste, religion, region, gender or wealth. Non-partisanship means serving whichever party is elected…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What do you understand by the terms ‘governance’, ‘good governance’ and ‘ethical governance’?
The World Bank's 1992 report Governance and Development defined governance as the manner in which power is exercised in the management of a country's economic and…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Discuss Mahatma Gandhi’s concept of seven sins.
In Young India of 22 October 1925 Gandhi published a list of seven social sins sent to him by a correspondent, so that readers would take them to heart and avoid them.…
Read the model answer →
QQ3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Analyse John Rawls’s concept of social justice in the Indian context.
In A Theory of Justice (1971) John Rawls described justice as fairness: the principles rational people would choose behind a veil of ignorance, in an original position…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.