“In spite of adverse environmental impact, coal mining is still inevitable for development.” Discuss.
Weigh both sides of the statement, the developmental necessity of coal and its environmental cost, and arrive at a reasoned position with examples.
Common trap: Most answers list pollution and stop. A top answer quantifies coal's place in India's energy mix, shows why substitutes cannot replace it quickly, and ends with how mining can be made cleaner rather than whether it should exist.
SyllabusDistribution of key natural resources across the world (including South Asia and the Indian sub-continent); factors responsible for the location of primary, secondary, and tertiary sector industries in various parts of the world (including India).
Model answer
10 marks · 150-word limitCoal meets over half of India's commercial energy needs and fuels about three-quarters of its electricity. With resources of about 315 billion tonnes (GSI, 1 April 2017), it is the cheapest secure domestic fuel, though mining scars land, water and air.
- Base-load power for 24x7 supply
- Coking coal for steel
- Domestic fuel, lower import bill
- Jobs and royalty in eastern states
- Forest loss and displacement
- Mine fires and subsidence
- Acid mine drainage, fly ash
- Highest CO2 per unit of energy
Why coal mining remains inevitable
- Energy security: All-India output of about 658 million tonnes in 2016-17, with Coal India alone at 554 million tonnes, still left imports near 190 million tonnes.
- Base-load and affordability: Solar and wind are intermittent and storage costly, so thermal plants anchor round-the-clock supply.
- Industrial needs: Steel, cement and fertiliser depend on coal; the National Steel Policy 2017 targets 300 million tonnes of steel capacity.
- Regional economy: Royalty, District Mineral Foundation funds (MMDR amendment, 2015) and jobs sustain Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh and Odisha.
Adverse environmental impact
- Land and forests: Open-cast mines strip forests, as in Hasdeo Arand, and displace tribal communities.
- Fires and pollution: Century-old fires in Jharia, acid mine drainage in the Damodar valley and fly ash degrade air, water and health.
- Climate: Coal is India's largest source of carbon dioxide, which sits uneasily with its Paris commitment of 40 percent non-fossil power capacity by 2030.
Reconciling the two
- Cleaner use: Coal washing, supercritical plants and the December 2015 emission norms (flue-gas desulphurisation) cut pollution.
- Responsible mining: Mine-closure plans, backfilling, land reclamation and a Rs 400 per tonne coal cess internalise part of the damage.
Coal is inevitable for India's development in the medium term, but not on present terms. Cleaner mining and combustion, honest rehabilitation and a planned shift to renewables, starting with the 175 GW target, can make coal a bridge fuel rather than a permanent dependence.
Read more — sources
- NCERTIndia: People and Economy (Class XII) — Ch. 5, Mineral and Energy Resources
- NCERTContemporary India – II (Class X) — Ch. 5, Minerals and Energy Resources
- OfficialMinistry of Coal, Annual Report 2017-18; GSI Inventory of Geological Resources of Indian Coal (as on 1 April 2017)
- OfficialIndia's Intended Nationally Determined Contribution to the UNFCCC (2015)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 1 2017
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.