Why did the 'Moderates' fail to carry conviction with the nation about their proclaimed ideology and political goals by the end of the nineteenth century?
Give the reasons, with evidence, why the Moderates lost credibility by about 1900, and keep a balance by noting what they achieved.
Common trap: Many answers simply list Moderate methods. The question asks why they failed to carry conviction, so reasons such as their narrow social base, faith in British justice and meagre gains, with the rise of Extremist critique, must be shown with dated evidence.
SyllabusThe Freedom Struggle — its various stages and important contributors/contributions from different parts of the country.
Model answer
10 marks · 150-word limitFrom 1885 the Moderates, led by Dadabhai Naoroji, Pherozeshah Mehta, Surendranath Banerjea and later G.K. Gokhale, sought reform within the Empire by constitutional agitation. By 1900 many Indians found them too timid, elitist and barren of results.
- Faith in British justice
- Methods: prayer, petition, protest
- Meagre gains like the 1892 Act
- Famine, plague, repression after 1896
- Extremist critique wins youth
Reasons for the failure
- Narrow social base: Congress drew on English-educated professionals of the presidency towns and did not mobilise peasants or workers.
- Faith in British liberalism: Belief that Britain would grant reform once informed clashed with a hostile bureaucracy.
- Mendicant methods: Resolutions, memorials and deputations were derided as political mendicancy; Aurobindo Ghose's New Lamps for Old series in 1893 attacked the Congress as unrepresentative and ineffective.
- Meagre results: The Indian Councils Act 1892 gave only indirect election and limited budget debate, while demands such as simultaneous ICS examinations were not met.
- Annual-session politics: Congress met three days a year, with no organisation or programme in between.
Context that hastened disillusionment
- Crises of the late 1890s: The famines of 1896–97 and 1899–1900 and harsh plague measures in Bombay deepened anger.
- Rise of assertive nationalism: Tilak's Ganapati and Shivaji festivals and his 1897 sedition trial offered a bolder, mass-based alternative; Curzon wrote in 1900 that the Congress was tottering to its fall.
Balance
- Lasting contribution: Naoroji's drain theory, Ranade's and Gokhale's economic critique and the demand for representative bodies built the intellectual foundation of Indian nationalism.
The Moderates failed to persuade because their means did not match their ends: a national goal pursued through elite, petitioning politics. Yet their economic critique of colonialism armed every later phase of the struggle.
Read more — sources
- NCERTOur Pasts – III (Class VIII) — Ch. 8, The Making of the National Movement: 1870s–1947
- BookBipan Chandra et al., India's Struggle for Independence
- BookSumit Sarkar, Modern India 1885–1947
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 1 2017
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.