Initially Civil Services in India were designed to achieve the goals of neutrality and effectiveness, which seems to be lacking in the present context. Do you agree with the view that drastic reforms are required in Civil Services? Comment.
Give a reasoned personal opinion on the view, supported by evidence; here say whether reforms must be drastic or incremental and why.
Common trap: Many answers agree blindly. A top answer separates what is broken (neutrality, tenure, accountability, specialisation) from what still works, and argues for deep but structural reform rather than dismantling the steel frame.
SyllabusRole of civil services in a democracy.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitSardar Patel defended the all-India services as the steel frame of the Union, protected by Articles 311 and 312, so that they could advise fearlessly and work impartially. Seven decades later, politicisation and rigid processes have dented both neutrality and effectiveness.
- Fixed tenure, insulated transfers
- Performance-based appraisal
- Domain specialisation
- Lateral talent
- Citizen-centric accountability
- Protection for honest decisions
Why neutrality and effectiveness appear to be lacking
- Politicisation: Frequent transfers and punitive postings, seen in the 2013 suspension of Durga Shakti Nagpal, encourage loyalty to ministers over rules.
- Generalist rigidity: Seniority-based promotion and short postings leave officers without depth in complex areas like finance, technology and health.
- Weak accountability: Appraisal has been largely confidential and inflated; outcomes rarely affect careers.
- Risk aversion: Fear of investigation for bona fide decisions leads to policy paralysis.
- Process over outcomes: Colonial-era rules, files and hierarchy favour compliance over results and citizen service, hurting effectiveness.
Reforms suggested and started
- Second ARC, 10th Report (2008): Recommended domain allocation, mid-career reviews and a Civil Services Law to codify values and protect neutrality.
- T.S.R. Subramanian v. Union of India (2013): The Supreme Court directed minimum tenure, Civil Services Boards for transfers, and the recording of oral instructions.
- Appraisal changes: A multi-source (360-degree) assessment was brought in for central empanelment of senior officers from 2015.
Assessment: drastic or deep reform?
- Case for drastic change: Piecemeal steps have been diluted, as Civil Services Boards have often been ignored by state governments.
- Case for caution: Neutrality cannot be legislated alone; it needs restraint by the political executive too. The service still delivers elections, disaster relief and the census at huge scale; dismantling security of tenure would deepen politicisation, not cure it.
- Since then: Lateral entry at Joint Secretary level (2018) and Mission Karmayogi (2020) have begun testing specialisation and competency-based training.
Reform must be deep rather than destructive: a statutory shield for neutrality, outcome-based careers, specialisation and citizen accountability. The goal is a steel frame that is also flexible, true to Patel's vision of fearless advice in a democratic setting.
Read more — sources
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission — 10th Report, Refurbishing of Personnel Administration (2008)
- OfficialSupreme Court of India — T.S.R. Subramanian v. Union of India, judgment of 31 October 2013
- BookM. Laxmikanth, Governance in India
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2017
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.