Critically examine the Supreme Court's judgement on 'National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014' with reference to appointment of judges of higher judiciary in India.
Set out what the Court held and why, then test that reasoning against its strengths and weaknesses for judicial appointments, ending with a balanced view.
Common trap: Answers often stop at 'NJAC struck down, collegium restored'. A top answer explains the specific defects the majority found, uses Justice Chelameswar's dissent for the other side, and addresses the reform of the collegium that the Court itself invited.
SyllabusStructure, organization and functioning of the Executive and the Judiciary.
Model answer
10 marks · 150-word limitThe Constitution (99th Amendment) Act and the NJAC Act, 2014 replaced the collegium with a six-member National Judicial Appointments Commission. On 16 October 2015, in Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v Union of India (the Fourth Judges case), a five-judge bench struck both down by 4:1.
- 1981First Judges case: executive primacy
- 1993Second Judges case creates collegium
- 1998Third Judges case: five-member collegium
- 201499th Amendment and NJAC Act
- Oct 2015NJAC struck down 4:1
- Oct 2017Collegium begins publishing resolutions
What the majority held
- Basic structure: Independence of the judiciary, including primacy of judges in appointments, is part of the basic structure, which the amendment violated.
- Defective design: Since any two members could veto a candidate, the Law Minister and two eminent persons could block the CJI and the two senior-most judges.
- Vague criteria: Eminent persons were undefined and chosen by a panel including the Prime Minister, opening the door to executive influence.
Critique of the judgement
- Judges choosing judges: The Constitution speaks of consultation, not concurrence; the collegium itself is a judicial creation of 1993 with no textual basis.
- Chelameswar's dissent: He found the collegium opaque and saw the NJAC as a check on unwholesome trade-offs within it, a view he pressed in 2016 by staying away from collegium meetings.
- Democratic legitimacy: An amendment passed almost unanimously by Parliament and ratified by states was set aside, sharpening executive-judiciary friction.
- Unresolved delays: Stalemate over the revised Memorandum of Procedure, ordered in December 2015, has slowed High Court appointments.
Assessment
- Partial victory: The Court admitted the collegium needs reform; publishing collegium resolutions from October 2017 is a modest step towards transparency.
The verdict protected judicial independence but left appointments in an unaccountable system. A transparent collegium with written criteria, a secretariat and a finalised Memorandum of Procedure, or a re-designed commission with judicial majority and no veto, would reconcile independence with accountability.
Read more — sources
- OfficialSupreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v Union of India, (2016) 5 SCC 1
- OfficialThe Constitution (Ninety-ninth Amendment) Act, 2014 and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014
- NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 6, Judiciary
- BookM. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2017
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.